The decision taken by the Game Awards did not fail to provoke a reaction on social networks.
Many fans denounce a lack of honesty on the part of the ceremony, which, according to them, would like to allow “Elden Ring” to obtain a second GOTY. Son DLC, “Shadow of the Erdtree“, was indeed one of the biggest successes of 2024. Many believe, however, that its expansion status should not allow it to be designated as the “game of the year”.
For other Internet users, extensions, remakes or remasters definitely deserve a price. The latter, however, seem to agree on one point: it should be in a category of its own. The GOTY would then remain reserved for a game released during the year.
Recognition, but they should have their own categories. A game that has been completely overhauled with new mechanics and storylines should be evaluated on its unique merits, separate from games that are entirely new releases. This would promote fairness in the award selection process and cater to the evolving landscape of gaming.
Section 1: Discussion on Honesty in Game Awards Criteria
Interviewer: World-Today News is delighted to have you both with us today as we discuss the reactions to the Game Awards and their recent decision to award “Elden Ring” as Game of the Year. Could you please share your thoughts on the controversy surrounding the lack of honesty in the award criteria?
Guest 1: Well, as a fan of the Game Awards for many years, I do understand the concern that some people have expressed about the criteria being unclear or subjective. It’s important for awards ceremonies to have clear guidelines and a transparent process for selecting winners. However, I feel that this year’s selection of Elden Ring as GOTY was fairly justified given its immense popularity and critical acclaim. While Shadow of the Erdtree was an excellent expansion, it was still part of an already established game, and therefore not exactly a “new” game.
Guest 2: I completely agree. The Game Awards should be representing the best games of the year, not just the ones that sell the most. If they’re going to include content updates or expansions in their criteria, there needs to be more clarity around that. It feels like “Elden Ring” was awarded GOTY partly because of its success in previous years and not entirely based on its 2024 release. I think creating a separate category for DLC and expansions would be a good solution to this issue.
Section 2: Justification for Extension Considerations
Interviewer: Transitioning to the topic of DLC and expansions being awarded alongside standalone games. Do you believe that there should be exceptions to this rule? For example, should exceptional content updates or expansions also be considered for Game of the Year?
Guest 1: I think it depends on the scope of the update/expansion and how substantial it is. If an update or expansion significantly improves an existing game or adds significantly new content, then it should definitely be considered for GOTY. However, if it’s just a small patch or update, I wouldn’t think it should take priority over a completely new game release.
Guest 2: Absolutely! Extensions, remakes, and remasters deserve
