– To put it diplomatically: It is very unfortunate, almost irresponsible, that PST formulates itself in this way, says extremism researcher Lars Gule to Dagbladet.
Gule reacts strongly to the fact that the Police Security Service (PST), by acting leader Roger Berg, already went out on Saturday and stated that the shooting in central Oslo on Saturday night was a «Extreme Islamist terrorist act».
–
– It is the backdrop for us, and then the police investigate whether it may be illness, health or other conditions that put the case in a different light, Berg told Dagbladet on Saturday afternoon.
PST has too raised the terrorist threat level in Norway from moderate to extraordinary in the wake of the episode, which is now called the Pride shooting. Two men were killed and 21 people were injured during the shooting at the gay bar London and the neighboring pub Per on the corner.
The two were killed outside the latter bar.
Inside for conversation
It has emerged that terror and murder suspect Zaniar Matapour (43) has been on PST’s radar since 2015, and that he was in a so-called concern call no later than May, which resulted in the security service not finding that action was needed.
Berg has stated to NTB that PST has been concerned that Matapour in 2015 was part of an “extremely Islamist contact network in Norway”, which is willing to commit violence, and which exists in both Oslo and elsewhere in Norway.
“Obvious problems”
The acting PST chief says the terror suspect 43-year-old has sympathized with IS and foreign fighters who have left Norway.
– He was part of some of these environments, which we thought there was reason to follow, and then a concern call is a common measure on our part, Berg tells Dagbladet.
Matapour’s defender John Christian Elden has stated that the client came into PST’s spotlight after he reacted to a Koran burning. On Sunday afternoon, the accused man has not yet taken a position on the question of guilt, as he has so far does not cooperate with the police during the interrogations.
Mental disorders
Elden has also stated to NTB that he “is not sure that there was any motive for the action”.
It has emerged that Matapour has a long history of mental illness, with associated medication. He has been on disability benefits since 2013, and has been convicted of drug and violent crimes.
Extremism researcher Gule reminds that PST the day after the massacre at Kongsberg in October went out and stated that the attack was probably terror. After three days, however, the police stated that the theory of mental illness was the dominant one, and the perpetrator Espen Andersen Bråthen is now sentenced to compulsory mental health care.
– It worries me that PST has not learned from the Kongsberg case, where there was also an embarrassing press conference: PST talked about this as terror, and of course this should be investigated. But the psychiatric side was absent in PST’s assessments. Then half a day passed, and then you went back to psychiatry, he says and continues:
– Now we have a new PST chief, who also establishes terror – but it is not PST as decides this! It must be investigated! The acting head of PST says, has a great impact on the public and undermines the Oslo police’s broader approach. They say this can also be psychiatry, says Gule.
Passed the perpetrator: – Shouted «allahu akbar»
– What PST could say is that this able to be terror, and then further investigation will show whether it was so or not. But that PST – which has the task of investigating the terrorist side of the case – is so bombastic, is quite a bit.
PST has been presented with the extremism researcher’s criticism, but has not had the opportunity to respond to it on Sunday afternoon.
– Hammer in hand
Gule believes that PST, by wording itself in this way, undermines the Oslo police district’s investigation. In addition, according to him, they have sat in a strange light with the concern conversation in May, which did not have any practical consequences for Matapour.
– In case it was terrorism and linked to an extreme network or environment, it was a serious mistake to lower the threat level for Islamist terror just ten days ago, and not to follow Matapour up after the conversation, the researcher states.
June 16 reported PST that they considered the terrorist threat from extreme Islamism as “somewhat reduced”.
“PST considers it LITTLE PROBABLE, just under 40% probability, that extreme Islamists will try to carry out terrorist acts in Norway in the next 18 months,” the security service said.
Gule believes that PST is too eager in the service, and has an easy time concluding with terrorism in cases they are investigating, as this is the agency’s main task.
– They undoubtedly have competence, but have a hammer in their hand and always see nails around them.
– Not weakened
During a press conference on Sunday afternoon, police attorney Børge Enoksen in the Oslo police district states that the terrorist charge has not yet been weakened.
– You say that you go broad, while PST has been quite clear that he has links to an extremely Islamist network. What do you think about the different ways to discuss this?
Transferred to prison
– We cooperate well with PST. It is relevant for us to investigate that hypothesis, but as of now, as we see the investigation, it is too early to conclude what is the reason for this particular incident, Enoksen told Dagbladet.
He states that the police district is working broadly with the case.
– It is still early, we have mentioned some of the hypotheses – hate crime, radicalism. And then we focus on his mental health, psychiatry – no one stands out significantly. It can also be a combination.
Sunday afternoon is Matapour transferred to prison.
– No physical network
Gule doubts that Matapour may have been part of a larger Norwegian Islamist community.
– There is no physical network. I have been worried that the angry communities that throw stones during Sian demonstrations could develop into a network – but there is nothing to suggest that, he says and continues:
Interrogation interrupted again
– It seems like spontaneous actions, and it does not seem to be the same young Muslims who participate time and time again – I have this from my own observations and politicians, the researcher says.
– Can be pure psychiatry
Gule believes that the available information about Matapour rather points in the direction that mental illness is behind the Pride shooting.
– I emphasize what has emerged about disability benefits, diagnosis and heavy medication, plus what defender Elden says – that it is too early to talk about any motive. It may be a “legal” way to suggest that this may just as well be about pure psychiatry, he says.
Gule considers it probable that what Matapour has been offended by is Sian’s Koran burns. What kind of network he is said to have entered into is unclear, but the 43-year-old may have communicated with an international Islamist environment on the internet rather than a physical environment in Norway.
–
– As the PST chief stated, it seems that there are many extreme Islamists in Norway – but that does not agree with my overview, he says and continues:
– And if it actually is is many in the Norwegian context, it is strange that PST lowered the terrorist threat a short time ago. That the acting chief now says it is an environment is startling. And indicates that one hand does not know what the other is doing in PST. It’s disturbing.
– Very vague
Gule reminds that the Norwegian visible Islamist milieu around the Prophet’s Ummah has been virtually dead since the autumn of 2015, when their spokesperson was arrested.
– The Prophet’s Ummah community was never large; they were top 10-15 in a kind of core, and had a sympathetic surrounding. In addition, they helped a number of young people to Syria. Then the environment disappeared as a formal network, and there is nothing to suggest that this network is alive.
Post gay hatred on Facebook
He emphasizes:
– If this guy [Matapour] has been on the periphery of the environment, and had contact with them, it is interesting – but as PST puts it, it seems very vague.
– Quite strange
Gule emphasizes that he can not completely rule out that this is a very secret and skilled environment.
– But I do not think so. Because if there really is something driven and security-conscious Islamists are good at, it’s weeding out people with mental problems. That he has been on disability benefits since 2013 is not something that has passed other Islamists by, the researcher says. And adds:
– If this environment is so hidden that you as a journalist and I as a researcher have not heard of it, they are a very safety-conscious environment. And they weed out insane people. Then PST’s assessment of the perpetrator as not dangerous in May will also be quite strange.
–