Hugo Awards Exclude Several Authors Due to China Concerns, Leaked Emails Reveal
Leaked emails have shed light on the exclusion of several authors from the prestigious Hugo Awards last year, raising concerns about potential offense to China. The Hugo Awards, well-renowned for recognizing exceptional science fiction literature, deemed authors Neil Gaiman, Paul Weimer, R.F. Kuang, and Xiran Jay Zhao ineligible as finalists despite receiving sufficient votes. Recently released emails highlighted the organizers’ worries about how these authors’ works might be perceived in China, according to a report by File 770, a notable science fiction outlet.
Controversy and Country Dynamics
The Hugo Awards ceremony was held in China last year, a fact that seemingly influenced the organizers’ decision. In a June email, Dave McCarty, the head of the 2023 award selection, emphasized the need to consider cultural and political sensitivities, given the differing laws and operational constraints in China. Works that explored topics around China, Taiwan, Tibet, and other contentious subjects would undergo close scrutiny, to assess whether it was safe to feature them in the award ballot. McCarty, as the head, stepped down from his position last month.
Uncovering Disparities and Unread Works
The unsettling revelation that administrators from the United States and Canada appeared to have exclusively read works from the Western world, despite China being the host country, prompted further scrutiny. It was discovered that Chinese authors’ books were largely absent from the administrators’ reading lists, raising the possibility that the concerns were rooted in a lack of familiarity rather than intentional exclusion.
“Because of this, it is possible some of these Chinese works were removed for reasons other than slating,” the report concludes, pointing towards the need for greater diversity and inclusivity at literary awards.
Organizer’s Apology
Organizer Diane Lacey, who publicly released the leaked emails, expressed remorse and acknowledged the pressure to vet nominated works sensitive to China. In an apology letter, Lacey reflected on the challenges faced and emphasized her keenness to ensure the success of the Hugo Awards, highlighting her awareness of the complexities of the Chinese political system.
While these leaked emails have brought to light the exclusion of certain authors from the Hugo Awards, the incident has also sparked deeper conversations about cultural representation, international collaboration, and the need for unbiased literary recognition.
© 2024 Nexstar Media Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.
