The New York Times recently asked eleven writers, critics, and musicians to share their favorite avant-garde jazz songs. Avant-garde jazz is a challenging subgenre that emerged as a desire to break away from the prescribed sounds of bebop and post-bop. It is driven by spontaneity and experimentation, and its rules are still being written.
The definition of avant-garde jazz has been a point of contention since its inception. Some argue that it doesn’t even feel like jazz at all, while others fuse poetry and polyrhythms to express a different side of the subgenre. One of its biggest advocates was saxophonist and bandleader John Coltrane, who pushed for the release of free jazz music on mainstream labels.
Today, the rules for avant-garde jazz are still being defined. The list of favorite songs shared by these musicians, authors, and critics represents a broad cross-section of avant-garde jazz then and now. Some of the favorites include “Longview” by Barre Phillips and John Surman, “Yeh Come T’ Be” by Jeanne Lee, “Peanut” by Sonny Sharrock, “Unity, Part I” by Frank Wright, “Science Fiction” by Ornette Coleman, “Max Brown” by Jeff Parker, “The Inflated Tear/Haitian Fight Song” by Rahsaan Roland Kirk, and “Triptych: Prayer/Protest/Peace” by Max Roach and Abbey Lincoln.
These songs showcase the diversity and experimentation within avant-garde jazz, challenging listeners and pushing the boundaries of the genre. Avant-garde jazz continues to evolve and redefine itself, and these songs are just a glimpse into its vast and ever-changing landscape.vocalizations, pushing the boundaries of what is considered traditional singing. In “Triptych: Prayer/Protest/Peace,” Lincoln’s voice is haunting and raw, evoking a range of emotions from sorrow to anger to hope. The piece is a powerful statement on the struggles of the civil rights movement and the need for change.
Listen on YouTube
◆ ◆ ◆
Nate Chinen, jazz critic and author
“The Creator Has a Master Plan” by Pharoah Sanders
Pharoah Sanders is a towering figure in the world of avant-garde jazz, and “The Creator Has a Master Plan” is one of his most iconic compositions. Clocking in at over 30 minutes, the piece is an epic journey that showcases Sanders’ virtuosic saxophone playing and his ability to create a spiritual and transcendent atmosphere. The song is a celebration of life, love, and unity, with Sanders’ saxophone soaring above the ensemble, guiding the listener through a series of dynamic and emotional passages. It’s a truly transformative listening experience that captures the essence of avant-garde jazz and its ability to push boundaries and challenge conventions.
Listen on YouTube
◆ ◆ ◆
Nicole Mitchell, musician and composer
“Lonely Woman” by Ornette Coleman
Ornette Coleman’s “Lonely Woman” is a seminal piece in the avant-garde jazz canon. The composition, which features Coleman’s distinctive alto saxophone playing, is haunting and melancholic, evoking a sense of isolation and longing. The piece is characterized by its free and open structure,The New York Times recently asked eleven writers, critics, and musicians to share their favorite avant-garde jazz songs. Avant-garde jazz is a challenging subgenre that emerged as a desire to break away from the prescribed sounds of bebop and post-bop. It is driven by spontaneity and experimentation, and its rules are still being written.
The definition of avant-garde jazz has been a point of contention since its inception. Some argue that it doesn’t even feel like jazz at all, while others fuse poetry and polyrhythms to express a different side of the subgenre. One of its biggest advocates was saxophonist and bandleader John Coltrane, who pushed for the release of free jazz music on mainstream labels.
Today, the rules for avant-garde jazz are still being defined. The list of favorite songs shared by these musicians, authors, and critics aims to represent a broad cross-section of avant-garde jazz then and now. Some of the songs mentioned include “Longview” by Barre Phillips and John Surman, “Yeh Come T’ Be” by Jeanne Lee, “Peanut” by Sonny Sharrock, “Unity, Part I” by Frank Wright, “Science Fiction” by Ornette Coleman, “Max Brown” by Jeff Parker, and “The Inflated Tear/Haitian Fight Song” by Rahsaan Roland Kirk.
Each song mentioned in the article offers a unique and experimental take on jazz, pushing the boundaries of the genre. Avant-garde jazz continues to evolve and challenge traditional notions of what jazz can be. The article concludes by encouraging readers to listen to the playlist of these avant-garde jazz songs and share their own favorites in the comments.
How does the article illustrate the ongoing debate surrounding the definition of avant-garde jazz?
The recent article by The New York Times asked eleven individuals in the jazz industry, including writers, critics, and musicians, to share their favorite avant-garde jazz songs. Avant-garde jazz is a unique subgenre that emerged as a response to the established sounds of bebop and post-bop, aiming to break away from traditional boundaries. It is characterized by its spontaneity, experimentation, and ongoing development.
The definition of avant-garde jazz has always been a subject of debate since its inception. While some argue that it doesn’t resemble jazz at all, others combine elements of poetry and polyrhythms to express a different side of the subgenre. John Coltrane, a renowned saxophonist and bandleader, played a significant role in advocating for the release of free jazz music on mainstream record labels.
Even today, the guidelines for avant-garde jazz remain fluid. The curated list of favorite songs shared by these respected individuals represents a diverse range of avant-garde jazz from its early days to the present. Among the favorites are “Longview” by Barre Phillips and John Surman, “Yeh Come T’ Be” by Jeanne Lee, “Peanut” by Sonny Sharrock, “Unity, Part I” by Frank Wright, “Science Fiction” by Ornette Coleman, “Max Brown” by Jeff Parker, “The Inflated Tear/Haitian Fight Song” by Rahsaan Roland Kirk, and “Triptych: Prayer/Protest/Peace” by Max Roach and Abbey Lincoln.
These songs display the diversity and experimental nature of avant-garde jazz, challenging listeners and pushing the boundaries of the genre. Avant-garde jazz continues to evolve and redefine itself, and these songs provide a glimpse into its ever-changing landscape.
One of the songs mentioned, “Triptych: Prayer/Protest/Peace” by Max Roach and Abbey Lincoln, combines Lincoln’s haunting vocalizations with powerful lyrics that express a range of emotions and perspectives related to the civil rights movement. Lincoln’s voice evokes sorrow, anger, and hope, making a profound statement about the need for change.
Another song highlighted is “The Creator Has a Master Plan” by Pharoah Sanders, a prominent figure in avant-garde jazz. This composition, lasting over 30 minutes, showcases Sanders’ exceptional skills on the saxophone and his ability to create a spiritual and transcendent atmosphere. The song celebrates life, love, and unity, taking the listener on an immersive journey through various dynamic and emotional passages. It exemplifies the transformative nature of avant-garde jazz and its ability to challenge conventions and push boundaries.
“Lonely Woman” by Ornette Coleman is also mentioned by Nicole Mitchell, a respected musician and composer. Coleman’s composition is recognized for its distinctive melody and unconventional structure, characteristics that are synonymous with avant-garde jazz.
Overall, the collection of favorite songs shared by these individuals provides a glimpse into the richness and diversity of avant-garde jazz. It is a genre that continues to evolve, redefine itself, and captivate listeners with its innovative and boundary-pushing approach to music.
This article beautifully captures the essence of avant-garde jazz, shedding light on its dynamic nature and the exhilarating power it holds. The exploration of spontaneity and the unwritten rules unveils a fascinating world of creativity and innovation. A must-read for all jazz enthusiasts!
This article beautifully captures the essence of avant-garde jazz, highlighting its captivating spontaneity and the way it defies traditional rules. A must-read for all music enthusiasts seeking an exhilarating sonic adventure!