Casey Cizikas scored twice for the winners.
Anthony Beauvillier, Brock Nelson, Anders Lee and Valtteri Filppula also scored for the Islanders, who had lost three of their previous four games.
Jordan Eberle and Cal Clutterbuck came out with two assists apiece, while Robin Lehner made 34 saves to give the Islanders a two-point lead past the Washington Capitals atop the Metropolitan Division at the day before a long-awaited duel between the two teams. The Islanders now have 81 points, one more than last season.
New York fans, very active on social media to express their bitterness over Tavares’ sudden departure last summer, booed him copiously when he jumped out onto the ice with his teammates for the period of warming up. The scenario recurred at the start of each period. They also chanted in chorus: “We don’t need you! », As well as other ridiculous slogans, throughout the meeting.
“They always make it difficult for the opponent,” Tavares said of the crowd. It was like that when I played here. Of course the tribute was appreciated, especially from the organization and the players on the other bench. It was appreciated to recognize the work I have done here over nine seasons. Everyone supported me, the organization and the guys on the other bench. “
Zach Hyman was the only one to blacken the scoresheet for the Maple Leafs, who saw their winning streak end at three. Garret Sparks made 31 saves.