SCJN orders to disclose full listing of federal prisons

Mexico Metropolis. With the conflict of positions of ministers on whether or not nationwide safety is put in danger, the Plenary Session of the Supreme Courtroom of Justice of the Nation (SCJN) ordered to disclose the whole listing of the Decentralized Administrative Physique for Prevention and Social Readaptation (OADPRS), that’s , federal prisons, together with its head, Commissioner Hazael Ruiz Ortega.

On this Tuesday’s session, the Overview Enchantment promoted by the Authorized Division of the Presidency of the Republic was reversed, towards decision RRA 6339/22-BIS, issued by the Nationwide Institute of Transparency, Entry to Info and Safety of Private Knowledge (Inai) on September 20, 2023.

“The powers of those areas don’t perform features that might endanger nationwide safety,” mentioned the minister answerable for the mission, Luis María Aguilar.

Within the Plenary session, the mission was authorised by seven votes, two partially in favor (Loretta Ortiz Ahlf and Jorge Mario Pardo Rebolledo) and two towards (Yasmín Esquivel Mossa and Lenia Batres Guadarrama).

“(Nay. Jail workers are put in danger,” Minister Lenia Batres warned when voting.

Luis María Aguilar argued that the features and powers of those officers aren’t straight associated to the operation of federal penitentiary facilities, since their powers typically have purely administrative features comparable to contracts, inner rules, personnel points. , coaching applications, amongst others, in addition to authorized recommendation.

The decision additionally orders the discharge of details about the top of Transparency and the Archives space and even the Commissioner for Prevention and Social Readaptation, Hazael Ruiz Ortega, appointed by President Andrés Manuel López Obrador on August 3, 2022.

“It’s proposed to declare the respective argument (of the Authorized Division) unfounded, since not less than the title of the general public servant (Hazel Ruiz) and her {photograph} are already public data, because the official web site of the Ministry of the Inside printed the information of his appointment,” he mentioned.

In the meantime, Minister Loretta Ortiz, who solid a vote partially in favor of the mission, warned and spoke out towards the mission, making certain that nationwide safety is put in danger by revealing the id of all federal jail personnel. .

“I contemplate that revealing the knowledge associated to the aforementioned public servants may have an effect on the inter-institutional coordination of the Decentralized administrative physique for Prevention and Social Readaptation, to the extent of violating the penitentiary system and thus nationwide safety, since these public servants could possibly be topic to of coercion and violence on their individual and household by organized crime, with the target of acquiring details about the substantive personnel of the decentralized physique and the traits of their coaching and coaching and, consequently, the response capability within the federal facilities of social readaptation,” he mentioned.