Quarterback Class at NFL Scouting Combine: Michael Penix Jr. Shines, J.J. McCarthy Impresses, and More
The NFL Scouting Combine is always an exciting event, but this year’s quarterback class has generated even more buzz than usual. With a deep pool of talented quarterbacks, there is much anticipation about how these prospects will perform. After spending five days in Indianapolis and speaking with coaches, scouts, and other media personnel, it’s clear that this quarterback class is polarizing and intriguing. Let’s dive into some of the biggest takeaways from the combine, starting with the quarterbacks.
Michael Penix Jr., the standout quarterback from Washington, is undoubtedly the most intriguing prospect in this class. Despite facing significant adversity, Penix has shown incredible resilience and growth. His performance at the combine only solidified his potential as an NFL quarterback. According to several NFL sources, Penix threw the ball better than any other quarterback at the event. He displayed accuracy, crispness, and confidence, leaving a strong impression on those who witnessed his workout. Additionally, Penix’s athleticism is often overlooked, but players who trained with him for the draft process believe he has the speed to run the 40-yard dash in the 4.4-second range. It’s safe to say that Penix has proven himself worthy of a first-round pick.
Another impressive quarterback at the combine was J.J. McCarthy from Michigan. McCarthy showcased excellent footwork and arm strength during his workout. While some coaches had concerns about his ability to vary his throws, McCarthy seemed to have addressed those issues and looked sharp. Standing at 6 feet 2 1/2 inches and weighing 219 pounds, McCarthy exceeded expectations with his physicality. His impressive three-cone time of 6.82 seconds further solidified his status as a top prospect.
Caleb Williams from USC, the 2022 Heisman winner, was a hot topic of discussion at the combine. Although he did not participate in throwing or workouts, Williams garnered attention due to his exceptional on-field abilities. Comparisons to Patrick Mahomes have been made, as both quarterbacks faced challenges with weak offensive lines and poor defenses. While some NFL coaches expressed concerns about Williams’ father’s involvement in his career, others believe that he is too talented to pass up. The circumstances surrounding a quarterback’s development in the NFL can greatly impact their success, making Williams an intriguing prospect.
Moving on to the wide receiver class, it was abundantly clear that this group is incredibly talented. Texas’ Xavier Worthy stole the show with his record-breaking 40-yard dash time of 4.21 seconds. Worthy’s speed and athleticism wowed the crowd, and his teammate AD Mitchell also impressed with a 4.34-second 40-yard dash time. Florida’s Ricky Pearsall had an outstanding day, running a 4.41-second 40-yard dash and showcasing impressive vertical jumping and broad jumping abilities. LSU’s Brian Thomas Jr. also turned heads with his impressive combine performance.
One player who generated intrigue among NFL personnel was Rome Odunze from Washington. While he may not be selected before Marvin Harrison Jr., some scouts expressed more interest in Odunze due to his elite ball skills and competitiveness. At 6 feet 3 inches and 212 pounds, Odunze possesses the physical attributes that make him a promising prospect.
On the defensive side of the ball, Marshawn Kneeland from Western Michigan stood out among defensive linemen and linebackers. Kneeland’s impressive three-cone time of 7.02 seconds and shuttle time of 4.18 seconds showcased his agility and quickness. His athleticism, combined with his size, makes him a highly sought-after prospect.
Braden Fiske, another breakout star from Western Michigan, also garnered attention at the combine. Coaches raved about Fiske’s interview and praised his relentless attitude on the field. His impressive broad jump, vertical jump, and 40-yard dash time further solidified his status as a top defensive tackle prospect.
Missouri’s Darius Robinson also left a lasting impression on coaches with his passion for playing defense. His size, combined with his impressive combine numbers, makes him an appealing prospect for many teams.
Toledo cornerback Quinyon Mitchell lived up to the hype surrounding him with his blazing-fast 40-yard dash time of 4.33 seconds. Mitchell’s athleticism and physicality make him a standout player from the MAC conference.
Alabama edge rusher Dallas Turner and Louisville running back Isaac Guerendo were two players who exceeded expectations at the combine. Turner’s impressive 40-yard dash time, vertical jump, and broad jump showcased his athleticism, while Guerendo’s speed and explosiveness made him one of the fastest running backs in combine history.
Lastly, Penn State once again proved its ability to produce exceptional athletes. Chop Robinson and Theo Johnson showcased their athleticism and versatility at the combine, impressing scouts with their impressive numbers.