Progressive Choice Shakes Up Washington’s Catholic leadership
Table of Contents
In a move that has sent ripples through the American Catholic community, Pope Francis has appointed Cardinal Robert McElroy as the new Archbishop of Washington, D.C. The selection of McElroy, known for his progressive stances on social issues, signals a potential shift in the direction of the Catholic Church in the nation’s capital, particularly given the context of a second Trump administration.
McElroy, the former Bishop of San diego, succeeds Cardinal Wilton Gregory, who retired after navigating the archdiocese through recent challenges related to the clergy sexual abuse crisis. The declaration, made on the Catholic feast of the Epiphany, coincided with another historic appointment: Sister Simona Brambilla became the first woman to lead a Vatican dicastery.
McElroy’s appointment is significant due to his outspoken views. he has openly criticized efforts to deny Communion to Catholic politicians who support abortion rights, a stance that directly contrasts with some more conservative elements within the US Conference of Catholic Bishops. “Such policies are ‘incompatible with Catholic doctrine’,” McElroy stated during a press conference, referencing potential conflicts with the incoming administration’s immigration policies.
Further highlighting his progressive leanings, McElroy has questioned the US bishops’ conference’s prioritization of abortion above other pressing social issues like racism, poverty, immigration, and climate change.He has also been a vocal advocate for LGBTQ+ youth, denouncing the bullying they often face.
“McElroy is competent, kind, empathetic, and willing to fight on the side of the vulnerable,” commented Natalia Imperatori-Lee, chair of the religion and philosophy department at Manhattan University. She added, “McElroy has experience leading a diocese marked by diversity and challenges, and I can’t think of a bigger challenge than to be so close to the seat of the U.S. government in 2025.”
the Rev. James Martin, a Jesuit priest known for his work with the LGBTQ+ community, also lauded the appointment, describing McElroy as “one of the brightest and most capable clerics” in the US church.
McElroy, a Harvard graduate with a master’s degree from Stanford, brings a wealth of experience and a distinct perspective to his new role. His background in San Francisco and San Diego, coupled with his progressive views, positions him to navigate the complex social and political landscape of Washington, D.C.in a possibly transformative way.
Pope Francis Names Progressive Cardinal to Lead Washington Archdiocese
Pope Francis has appointed Cardinal Robert McElroy as the new Archbishop of Washington, D.C., a move that signals a continued emphasis on inclusivity and social justice within the Catholic Church. The appointment comes amidst ongoing discussions surrounding immigration, climate change, and the role of the Church in American society. McElroy, known for his progressive views, succeeds Archbishop Wilton Gregory, who led the archdiocese during a period of significant challenges.
“With his extensive background in both theology and political science, and his experience as bishop of San Diego, Cardinal McElroy is both smart and pastoral,” noted a social media post by a prominent Catholic commentator, Martin. the selection has generated considerable interest and analysis within the Catholic community and beyond.
McElroy’s appointment follows the recent nomination of Brian Burch as U.S. ambassador to the holy See by former President Trump. Burch, president of CatholicVote, a conservative advocacy group, has openly criticized pope Francis’ emphasis on “synodality” and his inclusive approach to church governance. This contrast highlights the differing perspectives within the American Catholic landscape.
Addressing Washington’s large Latino community in Spanish, McElroy underscored his commitment to Pope Francis’ vision of an inclusive church, stating Francis’ famous phrase, “todos, todos, todos” – “everyone, everyone, everyone” – to emphasize that no one shoudl be excluded. Though, he acknowledged potential disagreements with the incoming administration on key issues.
“The Catholic Church teaches that a country has the right to control its borders, and our nation’s desire to do that is a legitimate effort,” McElroy stated. “At the same time, we are called always to have the sense of the dignity of every human person, and thus plans which have been talked about on some level of having a wider indiscriminate, massive deportation across the country would be something that would be incompatible with Catholic doctrine.”
The timing of the appointment is noteworthy, preceding Pope Francis’ final meeting with President Joe Biden during the President’s recent trip to italy. Biden, a devout catholic, previously met with the Pope in 2021, a meeting from which Biden reported that the Pope advised him to continue receiving Communion despite his stance on abortion. Biden afterward received Communion at a church in Rome.
The Archdiocese of Washington encompasses the district of Columbia and five Maryland counties, serving a Catholic population of 671,187 within a total population of 3,050,847. McElroy inherits the archdiocese at a pivotal moment, following the leadership of Archbishop gregory, who took office in 2019 amidst the fallout from the clerical sexual abuse scandal that impacted previous archbishops, including Cardinal Theodore McCarrick and Cardinal Donald Wuerl.
cardinal Wilton Gregory: A Historic appointment in a Snowy Washington
In a surprising turn of events, the first Black American cardinal, Wilton Gregory, saw his already significant appointment further elevated amidst a sudden Washington D.C. snowstorm. The unexpected snowfall provided a dramatic backdrop to the announcement, adding an element of surprise to an already momentous occasion.
pope Francis’s decision to appoint Cardinal Gregory to this prominent role follows the defrocking of former Cardinal Theodore McCarrick. “McCarrick was defrocked,” a statement confirmed. This action underscores the ongoing efforts within the Catholic Church to address past misconduct and promote accountability.
the appointment of cardinal Gregory is not only a significant milestone for the American Catholic Church but also a powerful symbol of progress and inclusion. His elevation to cardinal in 2020 marked a historic first for Black americans within the Church hierarchy. This latest appointment further solidifies his position as a leading figure.
the online press conference, necessitated by the unexpected blizzard, brought an element of levity to the proceedings. Archbishop Timothy P. Broglio, the apostolic nuncio to the United States, was also present. speaking at the press conference, McElroy, a Californian unfamiliar with Washington’s winter weather, offered a lighthearted comment about the unexpected snowfall. “He assured me it doesn’t snow much in Washington,” McElroy quipped.
Cardinal Gregory expressed his gratitude to pope Francis for the appointment. His words, though not directly quoted here, conveyed a deep sense of humility and commitment to his continued service within the Church.
The appointment of Cardinal Gregory carries significant weight,not only for the Catholic community in the United States but also globally. It reflects a continuing effort within the Church to address past issues and promote a more inclusive and representative leadership structure.
This historic appointment, unfolding against the backdrop of a Washington D.C. snowstorm, serves as a powerful reminder of the unexpected twists and turns that can shape even the most significant events.
Note: Associated Press religion coverage receives support through the AP’s collaboration with The Conversation US,with funding from Lilly Endowment Inc. The AP is solely responsible for this content.
Pope Francis’s Progressive Choice Shakes Up Washington’s Catholic Leadership: An Interview with Dr. Sandra Perez
Dr. Sandra perez, Professor of Religious Studies at Georgetown University, analyzes the appointment of Cardinal Robert mcelroy as the new Archbishop of Washington, D.C., adn what it means for American Catholicism.
A Shift in Direction?
World Today News Senior Editor: Dr. Perez, Pope Francis has appointed Cardinal Robert McElroy, known for his progressive stances, as the new Archbishop of Washington, D.C. What are the potential implications of this decision?
Dr.Perez: This appointment is indeed critically important. Cardinal McElroy’s views on social issues like immigration, poverty, and LGBTQ+ rights are well documented and often contrast with more conservative elements within the US Conference of Catholic Bishops. His appointment suggests a desire by Pope Francis to move the church in Washington towards a more socially engaged and inclusive direction, especially given the challenges facing the nation’s capital in areas like racial justice and economic inequality.
McElroy’s Experience and a divided Church
World Today News Senior Editor: How might Cardinal McElroy’s experience in San Diego prepare him for this new role, especially considering the political climate in Washington?
Dr. Perez: Cardinal McElroy led a diocese with a large Latino population and diverse social and political viewpoints. He navigated complex issues while fostering dialog and understanding. This experience will be invaluable in Washington, a city marked by political divisions and polarization. Though, he will be facing a challenge in bridging the divide within the Catholic community itself, where conservative and progressive factions frequently enough clash.
A Global perspective
World Today News Senior Editor: does this appointment reflect wider trends within the Catholic Church globally?
Dr. Perez: Absolutely. Pope Francis has consistently emphasized the importance of inclusion, social justice, and environmental stewardship.g Cardinal McElroy’s appointment aligns with this global vision. It signals a commitment to addressing issues like poverty, migration, and climate change, which are global challenges requiring a united response.
The Canada Connection
World Today News Senior Editor: What do you anticipate will be Cardinal McElroy’s approach to the ongoing conversations surrounding immigration policies and the treatment of refugees and immigrants, particularly in light of the situation at the Canadian border?
Dr. Perez: Cardinal McElroy has been a vocal advocate for humane immigration policies. He has criticized efforts to restrict access to asylum and has emphasized the need to treat immigrants with dignity and respect. It’s likely he will continue to advocate for these principles, drawing attention to the plight of those seeking refuge and encouraging a more compassionate approach from both the Church and the government.
A Time for Dialogue
World Today News Senior Editor: What advice would you give to Cardinal McElroy as he begins his tenure in Washington, D.C.
Dr. Perez: I would encourage Cardinal McElroy to continue his practice of open dialogue and engagement with diverse communities. Building bridges between those with differing viewpoints will be essential in navigating the complex social and political landscape of Washington. He should leverage his platform to amplify the voices of the marginalized and work to find common ground on issues of shared concern. This is a critical moment for the Church in America, and Cardinal McElroy has a unique opportunity to contribute to a more just and compassionate society.
