Piña calls on AMLO and Sheinbaum to affix the dialogue on judicial reform

Mexico Metropolis. The chief justice of the Supreme Court docket of Justice of the Nation (SCJN), Norma Piña Hernández, referred to as on President Andrés Manuel López Obrador and the digital president-elect, Claudia Sheinbaum Pardo, to dialogue on Monday to construct a unique proposal for reform of the PJF, as she said that if the present initiative is authorized there will probably be “setbacks” in human rights and Mexico would enter “into uncertainty.”

“The truth is that the reform doesn’t tackle the basis of the issue. Due to this fact, I wish to take this chance to ask each President López Obrador and the digital president, Dr. Claudia Sheinbaum, to affix this plural dialogue, and to open the door for us to share the findings of this Nationwide Assembly and thus analyze how the reform impacts not solely the way forward for justice, however of our whole nation,” he mentioned from the Tlatelolco College Cultural Heart.

Piña headed the final of the 14 boards of the Nationwide Assembly for a Safety and Justice Agenda convened by the PJF, which introduced collectively greater than 3,500 individuals from public servants, civil society, academia and the non-public sector within the final 5 months.

“Given the nationwide scenario, we should ask ourselves: The place have we failed, in order that, all through this nationwide journey, during which greater than 3,500 individuals from various, even antagonistic profiles have participated, we hear from all of them time and again: “that justice is distant, that justice is inhumane, that justice is a nightmare,” he mentioned.

Accompanied by solely 4 of her 10 colleagues, Alberto Pérez Dayán, Juan Luis González Alcántara Carrancá, Loretta Ortiz and Javier Laynez Pontisek, the top of the PJF acknowledged that “a reform is required” and that it should embrace adjustments to the Federal Judiciary, however she emphasised that so as to actually provide options to the primary wants of society by way of justice, the initiative have to be based mostly on an actual prognosis. To this finish, she mentioned, the conclusions of the boards will probably be helpful.

“The worst factor we might do is rush a prognosis, or make individuals suppose that the answer lies in eradicating these of us who’re dealing with this problem as a part of a system, however it’s not the system as an entire.

“We can not take the straightforward approach out. We can not begin from scratch. The complicated context during which our nation resides doesn’t permit for improvisation. This is not going to profit these searching for justice; quite the opposite, it represents a step backwards within the safety of human rights of individuals, placing in danger the continuity of the administration of justice in our nation,” he mentioned.

In response to the minister, if the Judicial Reform is authorized in its phrases, “essentially the most certified individual will now not be accountable for the publish. The one who will probably be in cost is not going to be the one who spent years learning, getting ready for the aggressive exams, however the most well-liked individual, the one who knew tips on how to relate effectively with the ‘energy teams’ which, mockingly, is without doubt one of the arguments of this reform, that’s, it would provoke what it’s attempting to eradicate. The truth is that the reform doesn’t tackle the basis drawback.”

The conclusions of the boards, which compile greater than 4,500 issues expressed within the thematic roundtables, will probably be processed in order that the Court docket can assemble another reform proposal. They will even be delivered to legislators and representatives of the Federal Authorities.

“All these inputs are already out there on the Assembly’s web site, excluding these generated in the present day, which we’ll publish in lower than every week. In a spirit of most transparency, we’re making out there to you every little thing collected by our workforce so that you could formulate your individual conclusions and proposals,” Piña mentioned.