Obese binman loses case over refusal to attend medical appointments

In recent news, a binman who was dismissed for being too obese has lost his unfair dismissal claim. The case has raised questions about the discrimination faced by overweight employees in the workplace and the legal protections available to them. This article will explore the details of the case and provide insights into the broader issue of weight discrimination in the workplace.


A binman who was overweight and suffered from asthma, diabetes, and gout, faced disciplinary action due to his refusal to attend medical appointments set up by his employer. Despite his claims of being “fit to work,” colleagues had reported him falling asleep in the lorry and refusing to do his job. The worker lost his case at the Workplace Relations Commission, which found that he had not been subject to discriminatory harassment or victimization because of his weight or medical conditions. The company had legitimate concerns about his physical and medical wellbeing and had put in place appropriate measures to get independent medical certification on his fitness to work. The complainant refused to attend appointments with an occupational health specialist, leading the firm to believe he had abandoned his employment by failing to participate in the disciplinary process. The complaints under the Unfair Dismissals Act 1977 and the Employment Equality Act 1998 were dismissed as not well-founded.


In conclusion, the case of the obese binman losing his unfair dismissal claim highlights the importance of employers providing their staff with adequate support and reasonable adjustments for those with medical conditions. It is essential that companies make an effort to accommodate their employees’ needs and not discriminate against them in any way. Employers must understand that, regardless of weight or other medical conditions, employees have a right to fair treatment in the workplace. We hope that this case serves as a reminder for employers to review and improve their policies, allowing for a more inclusive and diverse workplace for all.