Indonesia’s Parliamentary Threshold Debate: A Push for Electoral Reform
In a significant move toward electoral reform, Deputy speaker of the Indonesian People’s Consultative Assembly (MPR), Eddy Soeparno, has voiced strong support for abolishing the 4% parliamentary threshold. This proposal comes in the wake of the 2024 elections, where millions of votes were effectively discarded due to parties failing to meet the threshold.
Eddy, a seasoned politician from the National Mandate Party (PAN) and a political science doctorate from the University of indonesia, highlighted the plight of parties like the United Development Party (PPP) and the Indonesian Solidarity Party (PSI). The PPP narrowly missed the threshold with 3.99% of votes,while the PSI secured only 3.01%. “This means that there are voters whose choices were not represented as their parties failed to meet the threshold. Consequently, their votes were essentially lost,” Eddy stated in a written statement on January 17, 2025.
The 2024 elections saw a staggering 16 million votes rendered invalid due to the parliamentary threshold. Eddy argued that in a system without such a threshold, smaller parties could still secure representation by forming coalitions. “In parliament, they woudl have to merge with others and engage in dialog to establish joint factions,” he explained.
Parliamentary Discussions on the Horizon
Table of Contents
Deputy Speaker of the House of Representatives (DPR), Sufmi Dasco Ahmad, confirmed that the DPR would address the Constitutional Court’s (MK) ruling on the parliamentary threshold after the recess period, which runs from December 6, 2024, to January 20, 2025.The discussions will coincide with deliberations on the recently annulled presidential threshold, which the MK revoked in a ruling issued on January 2, 2025. “Yes, we’ll address it together,” Dasco told reporters at the MPR/DPR complex in Jakarta on January 7, 2025.
Omnibus Law to Tackle Political Reform
Deputy Chairman of Commission II of the DPR, Aria Bima, revealed plans to incorporate the parliamentary threshold issue into the omnibus law on political reform. “That’s the plan,” Bima told Tempo on January 7, 2025, adding that discussions would begin after the recess.The Constitutional Court’s decision on February 29, 2024, annulled the 4% parliamentary threshold stipulated in Law No. 7 of 2017 on General Elections (Election Law). The court ruled that the provision violated the principles of people’s sovereignty,electoral justice,and constitutional legal certainty. However,this landmark ruling will only take effect for the 2029 elections,as Article 414,Paragraph (1) of the Election Law remains applicable for the 2024 elections.
Key Points at a Glance
| Topic | Details |
|—————————-|—————————————————————————–|
| Parliamentary Threshold | 4% threshold annulled by Constitutional Court, effective for 2029 elections |
| 2024 Election Impact | 16 million votes discarded due to threshold |
| Proposed Reform | Abolish threshold to ensure representation of smaller parties |
| Next Steps | Discussions to be held post-recess, incorporated into omnibus law |
A Call for broader Representation
The push to abolish the parliamentary threshold underscores a growing demand for a more inclusive electoral system. By ensuring that smaller parties have a voice in parliament, Indonesia could foster greater political dialogue and representation.
For the latest updates on this developing story, click here to follow Tempo on Google News.
As Indonesia navigates this pivotal moment in its political landscape, the debate over the parliamentary threshold serves as a reminder of the importance of electoral justice and the need to ensure that every vote counts.
Indonesia’s Electoral Reform: A deep Dive into the Parliamentary Threshold Debate
In the wake of the 2024 Indonesian elections, the issue of the parliamentary threshold has sparked significant debate.With 16 million votes rendered invalid due to the 4% threshold, calls for electoral reform have intensified. Deputy Speaker Eddy Soeparno has been a vocal advocate for abolishing the threshold, emphasizing the need for broader portrayal.To shed light on this pivotal issue, we spoke with Dr. aditya Wijaya, a political scientist and electoral reform expert, to discuss the implications of the parliamentary threshold and the potential for change in Indonesia’s political landscape.
The Impact of the 4% Parliamentary Threshold
Senior Editor: Dr. Wijaya, thank you for joining us. The parliamentary threshold has been a contentious issue in indonesia, especially after the 2024 elections.Can you explain how this threshold affects voter representation?
Dr. Aditya Wijaya: Certainly. The 4% parliamentary threshold means that parties failing to secure at least 4% of the national vote are excluded from parliamentary seat allocation. In the 2024 elections, this led to 16 million votes being essentially discarded. Parties like the United Development Party (PPP) and the Indonesian solidarity Party (PSI) narrowly missed the threshold, leaving their voters unrepresented. This undermines the principles of electoral justice and inclusivity, as it silences the voices of millions of citizens.
the Constitutional Court’s Ruling
Senior Editor: The Constitutional Court recently annulled the 4% threshold, but it won’t take effect until 2029. What does this ruling signify for Indonesia’s electoral system?
Dr. Aditya Wijaya: The Court’s decision is a landmark moment. It ruled that the 4% threshold violates the principles of people’s sovereignty, electoral justice, and constitutional legal certainty. However,the ruling’s delayed implementation until 2029 highlights the complexities of electoral reform. It gives lawmakers time to design a more inclusive system, but it also means that the current threshold will remain in place for the next election cycle, continuing to exclude smaller parties.
Proposals for Electoral Reform
Senior Editor: Deputy Speaker Eddy Soeparno has proposed abolishing the threshold entirely. What are the potential benefits and challenges of such a reform?
Dr. Aditya Wijaya: Abolishing the threshold would ensure that all votes count, fostering greater political inclusivity. Smaller parties coudl still secure representation by forming coalitions in parliament, encouraging dialog and compromise. Though, there’s a risk of fragmenting the political landscape, which could complicate governance. Striking a balance between inclusivity and stability will be crucial. The omnibus law on political reform, currently under discussion, could provide a framework for addressing these challenges.
Looking Ahead: The Road to 2029
Senior Editor: What steps should Indonesia take to implement a more inclusive electoral system by 2029?
Dr. Aditya Wijaya: First, policymakers need to engage in comprehensive consultations with stakeholders, including political parties, civil society, and voters. Second, they should explore choice mechanisms, such as lowering the threshold or introducing proportional representation systems, to ensure fair representation. public awareness campaigns will be essential to educate voters about these reforms and their importance. It’s a significant undertaking, but one that could strengthen Indonesia’s democracy and ensure that every vote counts.
Final Thoughts
Senior Editor: Dr. Wijaya, thank you for your insights. As indonesia navigates this pivotal moment in its political landscape, the debate over the parliamentary threshold serves as a reminder of the importance of electoral justice and the need for inclusive representation.
Dr. Aditya Wijaya: It’s my pleasure. This is a critical opportunity for Indonesia to build a more inclusive and representative democracy. I’m hopeful that with thoughtful reform, we can create a system that truly reflects the will of the people.
