Picture from:
When watching animation, do you think about the real world?laws of physicsHow does it compare with the performance in the play?Japanese cartoonist cartoonistMizuho Takayamarecently complained about animation“The Burial of Florian”Among them, there is a scene of human figures reflected on the water surface, which does not conform to the laws of physical optics in reality.This statement immediately triggered discussions among netizens, and the following will followZhaiZhai NewsLet’s take a look at what kind of picture performance caused such a big discussion~~
The original content is here
“I happened to notice this composition in Chapter 16 of “The Burial of Florian”. This kind of water reflection is optically impossible. In other words, it can’t be captured in real shots. I don’t know if the production team did this on purpose. Where is the painting? Or do you not know that this phenomenon is impossible?”
Picture from:
“Not only the episode “The Burial of Florian”, I feel like I have seen similar examples in many works recently. Although I forgot which works… but the quality of “The Burial of Florian” is so high. I was surprised that Gao’s works can be painted like this.”
Picture from:
Japanese cartoonistMizuho TakayamaRecently inＸPost a post and talk about animation“The Burial of Florian” Chapter 16among,ZaneIn the scene of fishing by the river, the reflection on the water surface does not match the realistic optical phenomenon…
Mizuho Takayama has participated in the production of robot animations such as “Mobile Suit Z Gundam” and “Armored Trooper Bodemuz” in the past, and has also drawn many“Mobile Suit Gundam” seriesRelated comics
Picture from:
Picture from:
Picture from:
This is the scene where he had objections to the painting method
Picture from:
Picture from:
The following isMizuho TakayamaDrawing diagram…
If the camera shoots from behind the head, it stands to reason that it can only capture the reflection of the sky, but not the reflection of the person.
Picture from:
Therefore, it is necessary to make people lean forward extremely until they are about to fall into the water.
Picture from:
Otherwise, we need to lift the entire water surface to achieve this kind of composition.
Picture from:
Mizuho TakayamaThis correction immediately sparked discussion among netizens. Some people said they had never noticed this. Some people think that being able to directly ignore the laws of physics in pursuit of visual expression is the advantage of animation as a creative form. Of course, some people complained about him, and they were just nitpicking!
Mizuho TakayamaGo on…
“What I want to ask is, should this hypocritical composition be regarded as a “consensus on performance techniques” and be fully accepted?”
Picture from:
“I can also understand that this kind of performance is intended to use the water surface as a mirror to express the intention of ‘looking at oneself in the water and confronting oneself in the heart’…”
Picture from:
(@д＠) But this kind of reflection composition is really beautiful…
Some information comes from the Internet ( @mizpitogetterAnikobin )
