Home » News » Manslaughter Charge Dropped in Subway Case

Manslaughter Charge Dropped in Subway Case

A New York City courtroom is grappling with the complex case of Daniel Penny, a former Marine accused of fatally choking a homeless man on a subway train.After days of deliberation, jurors have‍ failed to ⁢reach a unanimous⁣ verdict on the most serious charge against Penny: second-degree manslaughter.

Judge Maxwell Wiley, presiding over the case,​ dismissed the ‍manslaughter charge on Thursday, allowing jurors to focus ⁢on the lesser charge‍ of criminally ⁣negligent homicide. This decision came after the jury sent two notes indicating they were deadlocked on the⁤ manslaughter count, which carries a potential 15-year prison sentence.

“You are now free to consider⁢ count two. Whether that makes any difference or not, I have no idea,” ‍Judge Wiley told the jurors, referring to the remaining charge of criminally negligent homicide, which carries a maximum sentence of four years.

The case has sparked ⁤intense public debate and protests in New ‌York ‍City. ‌ Penny’s attorneys argue ⁢that he acted in ⁢self-defense, restraining Jordan Neely, a 30-year-old homeless man, to protect ​other passengers on the train. ​They claim Neely was behaving erratically,⁣ asking for money and​ threatening to ‍return to jail.

Prosecutors, though, contend that‌ Penny‍ held Neely in‌ a fatal chokehold for an extended‍ period, ‌leading to his death. “He was trying to protect others on the train,” ⁢Penny’s lawyer, Thomas Kenniff, ‌told the court.

The trial,which lasted a month,featured a range of evidence,including bystander videos of the ​incident,911 calls,police body camera footage,and testimony from witnesses. Neely’s family members have been present throughout the proceedings,watching the video ⁤of the subway confrontation repeatedly. Neely’s father has‌ also filed a civil lawsuit against Penny.

Neely, known for his Michael Jackson impersonations ​in Times Square, had a history of⁤ arrests for offenses such as ‍fare evasion,‌ theft, and assault. His family has stated that he struggled with mental health issues stemming from a traumatic event in his past:⁤ the murder ⁢of his mother by her ⁤boyfriend over 15 years ago.

The jury ‍will resume deliberations‍ next week, attempting to reach a verdict on the ​remaining charge of criminally negligent homicide.


please provide me with the ⁤context or information you’d ⁢like me⁢ to ⁤respond to. I need a⁤ prompt or question to ⁤get started! 😄



For​ example, ‍you could ask me:



* ⁢**To wriet something creative:** ‌”Can you write a short story about a cat ‌who ‍goes on an adventure?”

* **To answer a question:** “What is ​the capital of​ France?”

* **To translate something:** “How do you say ‘hello’ in Spanish?”

* **To summarize text:** “Can you summarize the plot of the movie Inception?”



I’m excited to see what you‍ come up with! ✨
×
Avatar
AI Chatbot
World Today News Chatbot
Hello, would you like to find out more details about
New York City courtroom is grappling with the complex case of <a href="http://www.world-today-news.com/protesters-demand-justice-for-homicide-victim-in-new-york-subway-incident/" title="Protesters Demand Justice for Homicide Victim in New York Subway Incident">Daniel Penny</a>, a former Marine accused of fatally choking a homeless man on a subway train.After days of deliberation, jurors have‍ failed to ⁢reach a unanimous⁣ verdict on the most serious charge against Penny: second-degree manslaughter. </p>\r\n<!-- /wp:paragraph -->\r\n<!-- wp:paragraph -->\r\n<p>Judge Maxwell Wiley, presiding over the case,​ dismissed the ‍manslaughter charge on Thursday, allowing jurors to focus ⁢on the lesser charge‍ of criminally ⁣negligent homicide. This decision came after the jury sent two notes indicating they were deadlocked on the⁤ manslaughter count, which carries a potential 15-year prison sentence. </p>\r\n<!-- /wp:paragraph -->\r\n<!-- wp:paragraph -->\r\n<p>"You are now free to consider⁢ count two. Whether that makes any difference or not, I have no idea," ‍Judge Wiley told the jurors, referring to the remaining charge of criminally negligent homicide, which carries a maximum sentence of four years.</p>\r\n<!-- /wp:paragraph -->\r\n<!-- wp:paragraph -->\r\n<p>The case has sparked ⁤intense public debate and protests in New ‌York ‍City. ‌ Penny's attorneys argue ⁢that he acted in ⁢self-defense, restraining Jordan Neely, a 30-year-old homeless man, to protect ​other passengers on the train. ​They claim Neely was behaving erratically,⁣ asking for money and​ threatening to ‍return to jail. </p>\r\n<!-- /wp:paragraph -->\r\n<!-- wp:paragraph -->\r\n<p>Prosecutors, though, contend that‌ Penny‍ held Neely in‌ a fatal chokehold for an extended‍ period, ‌leading to his death. "He was trying to protect others on the train," ⁢Penny's lawyer, Thomas Kenniff, ‌told the court. </p>\r\n<!-- /wp:paragraph -->\r\n<!-- wp:paragraph -->\r\n<p>The trial,which lasted a month,featured a range of evidence,including bystander videos of the ​incident,911 calls,police body camera footage,and testimony from witnesses. Neely's family members have been present throughout the proceedings,watching the video ⁤of the subway confrontation repeatedly. Neely's father has‌ also filed a civil lawsuit against Penny. </p>\r\n<!-- /wp:paragraph -->\r\n<!-- wp:paragraph -->\r\n<p>Neely, known for his Michael Jackson impersonations ​in Times Square, had a history of⁤ arrests for offenses such as ‍fare evasion,‌ theft, and assault. His family has stated that he struggled with mental health issues stemming from a traumatic event in his past:⁤ the murder ⁢of his mother by her ⁤boyfriend over 15 years ago. </p>\r\n<!-- /wp:paragraph -->\r\n<!-- wp:paragraph -->\r\n<p>The jury ‍will resume deliberations‍ next week, attempting to reach a verdict on the ​remaining charge of criminally negligent homicide. </p>\r\n<!-- /wp:paragraph --> <br/> please provide me with the ⁤context or information you'd ⁢like me⁢ to ⁤respond to. I need a⁤ prompt or question to ⁤get started! 😄 <br /><br />\r\n<br /><br />\r\nFor​ example, ‍you could ask me:<br /><br />\r\n<br /><br />\r\n* ⁢**To wriet something creative:** ‌"Can you write a short story about a cat ‌who ‍goes on an adventure?"<br /><br />\r\n* **To answer a question:** "What is ​the capital of​ France?"<br /><br />\r\n* **To translate something:** "How do you say 'hello' in Spanish?"<br /><br />\r\n* **To summarize text:** "Can you summarize the plot of the movie Inception?"<br /><br />\r\n<br /><br />\r\nI'm excited to see what you‍ come up with! ✨ ?">
 

By using this chatbot, you consent to the collection and use of your data as outlined in our Privacy Policy. Your data will only be used to assist with your inquiry.

Leave a Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.