Kowloon Park Animals Suffer During Pool Cleaning, Sparking Outrage
Table of Contents
published:
A routine pool cleaning at Kowloon Park’s Chinese Garden on February 23, 2025, has triggered widespread condemnation after numerous Brazilian turtles and fish were allegedly left to suffer, exposed to the elements. The incident, involving a large pool teeming with aquatic life, has drawn criticism from animal welfare advocates who accuse park staff of negligence and cruelty. The controversy centers around the draining of the pool,reportedly without adequate measures to protect the animals.
The controversy began when staff from the Kobun Police drained the pool, seemingly without adequate measures to safeguard the animals residing within. Dozens of Brazilian turtles and a multitude of fish were left stranded, their lives hanging in the balance as the water receded, leaving them vulnerable to the harsh sun. The lack of a prior warning or notification regarding the draining of the pool has also been criticized.
Abang, the founder of the animal rescue association “Turtway,” responded to an urgent call for help and arrived at the scene to assess the situation. He described what he witnessed as nothing short of “outrageous and cruelty to animals.” The scene reportedly included fish struggling in the mud and turtles desperately searching for water.
The fish and turtle were fried dry.Abang, founder of Turtway
Abang further alleged witnessing disturbing behaviour from a worker, claiming the worker was “dropping the turtle on the ground and using it. Kicking them.” These allegations have added fuel to the firestorm of criticism directed at the park and its staff.
the dire circumstances prompted Abang to instantly notify the Aihui Association, hoping they could assist in rescuing the imperiled creatures. Though, with neither Abang nor Aihui able to ascertain ownership of the animals, the situation escalated, leading to a call for police intervention.The lack of clarity regarding ownership further complex rescue efforts.
According to Abang,citizens alerted him to the suspected improper cleaning procedures,noting the absence of any prior warning or notification regarding the draining of the pool. the workers, it is claimed, proceeded to remove the water without regard for the well-being of the turtles and fish. This lack of communication and apparent disregard for animal welfare has sparked public outrage.
Abang recounted the distressing scene he encountered upon arrival:
At least four fish were struggling and jumping in the mud, and some of the fish were dried out, with fish nearly one foot long and 10. A turtle was looking for water at the bottom of a nearly dry pond, struggling to survive, wich was very pitiful.Abang, founder of Turtway
The situation was further compounded by the desperate actions of some turtles, who, in their parched state, reportedly mistook dying fish for food and attempted to consume them. This grim detail underscores the severity of the animals’ suffering.
This is not the first time the leisure and Cultural Affairs Bureau has faced scrutiny over similar incidents.Abang pointed to a prior occurrence at the Fengshui Pool in Lingnan, where the draining of water led to harm for the aquatic inhabitants. he expressed his dismay, stating, “Only one month later, the words are still in my ears. Today, the same thing happened again in Kowloon Park. It’s really unacceptable.” This highlights a pattern of alleged negligence within the bureau’s management of aquatic environments.
The Leisure and Cultural Affairs Bureau also manages Lai Chi Kok Park, where a similar incident occurred on January 20 of last month. Cleaning workers allegedly drained a sink without removing the turtles and fish, leaving them to suffer in the exposed conditions. This further reinforces concerns about the bureau’s commitment to animal welfare.
Following the arrival of the police at Kowloon Park,the owners involved reportedly acknowledged the inappropriateness of their animal treatment during the pool cleaning process. They pledged to implement improvements and enhance supervision of frontline employees.Afterward, the pool was refilled, and the surviving animals were returned to their habitat. the dry pool turtle was taken away.While this response is a step in the right direction, critics argue that more systemic changes are needed to prevent future incidents.
abang emphasized the inherent vulnerability of abandoned animals,stating:
It is indeed already miserable that animals are abandoned. they have to endure being treated like objects every time they wash the sink. in fact, they can treat living things lightly, and it is done by normal people who care about animals. Seeing someone letting the fish dry up Waiting for death, throwing the turtle slightly higher or kicking it with your feet is already inappropriate and cruel to treat animals.Abang,founder of Turtway
He urged the Leisure and Cultural Affairs Bureau to provide more extensive training for its employees,fostering greater awareness and sensitivity towards animal welfare. Abang expressed concern that Hong Kong’s animal care culture should not “regress.” The call for improved training underscores the need for a more proactive approach to animal welfare within the bureau.
The Leisure and Cultural Affairs Bureau has a history of animal neglect. In September 2018,a similar incident occurred at “Lingnan Wind” in Lai Chi Kok Park. Citizens discovered more than 10 fish lying at the bottom of a drained pond, dying. The association for Caring for Animals condemned the actions of the Leisure and Cultural Affairs Bureau. The department responded that the pond was only for tourists to watch, and was not for raising fish and other animals. It also pointed out that the fish were fished up and moved to another small pool during cleaning, but the front did not respond to the death of multiple fish.This history of similar incidents raises serious questions about the bureau’s commitment to animal welfare and its ability to learn from past mistakes.
The situation remains under inquiry, with further updates expected as the story develops. the public and animal welfare advocates will be closely monitoring the investigation and the actions taken by the Leisure and Cultural Affairs Bureau to prevent future incidents.
Kowloon Park Tragedy: Neglect or Systemic Failure in Hong Kong’s Animal Welfare?
“The Kowloon Park incident isn’t an isolated case; it highlights a disturbing pattern of animal neglect within Hong kong’s public spaces.” —Dr. Vivian lee, renowned zoologist and expert in animal welfare legislation.
Editor: Dr. Lee, the recent incident at Kowloon Park, where numerous turtles and fish suffered during a pool cleaning, has sparked outrage. Can you shed light on the severity of this situation and its implications for animal welfare in Hong Kong?
Dr. Lee: The Kowloon Park incident is indeed deeply troubling. The alleged suffering of the brazilian turtles and fish, left exposed and vulnerable during a seemingly routine pool cleaning, speaks volumes about a lack of proper protocols and training regarding the humane treatment of animals in public spaces. The sheer scale of suffering—with numerous aquatic animals perishing or enduring severe distress—underlines the gravity of the negligence. This isn’t just about a few fish; it represents a broader failure to prioritize animal welfare within established procedures. The key here is recognizing this as a systemic issue, not a singular event. This situation highlights the inadequate provisions for aquatic animal care within public spaces and underscores the urgent need for reform.
Editor: Abang, the founder of Turtway, described the scene as “outrageous and cruel.” What measures should be in place to prevent such events and are these incidents isolated or part of a larger trend?
Dr. Lee: Abang’s description is horrifyingly consistent with eyewitness accounts of similar incidents. The lack of adequate safeguards, the alleged mistreatment of animals by staff, and the absence of prior warnings to the public all point towards a serious lack of concern for animal wellbeing. It’s crucial to establish robust standard operating procedures for cleaning public aquariums and ponds. This includes mandatory training for all staff involved in animal care, emphasizing humane handling and appropriate responses in case of emergencies. We also need clear protocols for draining and cleaning,emphasizing the safety and welfare of aquatic life. These protocols must be strictly enforced and regularly audited to check that safety precautions are being put in place. Sadly, the Kowloon Park case is not an isolated one. reports of animal suffering during similar cleaning operations in other Hong Kong parks suggest a systemic issue requiring immediate attention. We’ve seen similar patterns in other countries, highlighting the need for rigorous and consistent animal care guidelines across jurisdictions.This needs to be dealt with on multiple fronts, from adequate training to legislative reform.
Editor: What specific actions should the Leisure and Cultural Affairs Department take to remedy this, and what role can the public play in ensuring improved animal welfare?
Dr. Lee: The Leisure and Cultural Affairs Department must instantly undertake several crucial steps. First, a full, clear investigation into the incident must be conducted, leading to disciplinary action against any individuals found responsible for negligence or cruelty. This must also be accompanied by the implementation of a thorough training program for all staff, emphasizing humane animal handling techniques and emergency procedures. The progress and strict enforcement of detailed protocols for handling animals during maintenance work is paramount. Moreover, improved communication and openness with the public before large-scale maintenance operations could help to mitigate potential harm.
The public plays a pivotal role too. Citizens should be empowered to report instances of animal neglect, and authorities must ensure a readily accessible and responsive reporting mechanism. Public awareness campaigns highlighting the importance of animal welfare,especially in the context of public spaces,are highly necesary. We need to promote a culture of responsibility and accountability where animal wellbeing is genuinely prioritized.
Editor: Beyond immediate responses, what long-term changes would you recommend to enhance animal welfare practices in Hong Kong’s public spaces?
Dr. Lee: Long-term improvements require legislative changes.We need stronger animal welfare laws with stricter penalties for neglect and cruelty, and robust enforcement mechanisms. This is essential to fostering a culture of respect for all living beings. it’s not just about laws; it’s also about raising public awareness. Educating people on the importance of animal welfare and equipping them with the knowledge to act responsibly is key to bringing about enduring change. Regular audits and inspections of animal care facilities in public spaces also improve standards of care over time. By investing in appropriate resources and personnel, Hong Kong can create a greener and more humane public habitat for future generations.Along with this, more funding and support for animal rescue organizations are vitally significant. Organisations like Turtway play a crucial role in providing immediate aid and advocating for stronger protection of animals.
Editor: What is the ultimate message you want to convey regarding the Kowloon Park incident and its broader implications?
dr. Lee: The Kowloon Park incident serves as a stark reminder that the welfare of animals in our public spaces can’t be an afterthought. It demands that we prioritize humane treatment and implement robust safeguards against animal suffering.It’s not just a matter of cleaning a pool; it’s about upholding our ethical responsibility to all living beings—an aspect that is crucial for the preservation of a humane society in Hong Kong. We must collectively make a commitment to prevent a recurrence of this tragedy and work towards a more compassionate and equitable future for animals within our communities. We need robust and transparent systems, dedicated resources, and a shared commitment to animal welfare to ensure this isn’t repeated. Let’s use this tragic incident as a catalyst for change.
What are your thoughts on this disturbing incident? Share your opinions and suggestions in the comments below!
Hong Kong’s Animal Welfare Crisis: A Kowloon Park Tragedy and the Path Forward
Is a single incident of animal neglect at Kowloon Park truly representative of a much larger systemic failure in Hong Kong’s animal welfare practices? The answer, according to leading animal welfare expert Dr. Anya Sharma, is a resounding yes.
interview with dr. Anya Sharma, Leading Expert in Animal Welfare and Conservation
Editor: Dr.Sharma,the recent incident at Kowloon Park,where numerous turtles and fish suffered during a pool cleaning,has ignited widespread public outrage. Can you elaborate on the seriousness of this situation and its broader implications for animal welfare in Hong Kong?
Dr. Sharma: The Kowloon Park incident is deeply disturbing and,sadly,not an isolated event. The alleged suffering of the brazilian turtles and other aquatic animals, left exposed and vulnerable during what should have been a routine pool cleaning, underscores a systemic failure in animal care protocols and training within Hong Kong’s public spaces. The scale of the suffering—with numerous animals perishing or enduring severe distress—demonstrates unacceptable negligence.This isn’t simply about a few fish; it highlights a broader lack of prioritization of animal welfare within established procedures. We must recognize this as a systemic issue requiring immediate and comprehensive reform. The inadequate safeguards demonstrated in this case point towards a deficient understanding and implementation of best practices for aquatic animal care in public settings.
Editor: The founder of Turtway, Abang, described the scene as “outrageous and cruel,” alleging mistreatment of the animals by park staff. What specific measures should be in place to prevent similar tragedies, and are these incidents part of a larger trend?
Dr.Sharma: abang’s account aligns with eyewitness reports from similar incidents in other Hong Kong parks, tragically suggesting a disturbing pattern rather then an anomaly.To prevent such catastrophes, we need a multi-pronged approach. Firstly, robust standard operating procedures are crucial for the cleaning and maintenance of all public aquariums and ponds. This involves mandatory and comprehensive training for every staff member involved in animal care, focusing on humane handling, emergency response protocols, and a deep understanding of species-specific needs. We also need clearly defined protocols for draining and cleaning procedures, putting animal safety at the very forefront. These must incorporate detailed steps for safely relocating animals and must be strictly enforced with regular, rigorous audits. Importantly, consistent oversight and accountability mechanisms must be in place to ensure these protocols are being followed to the letter. There must be consequences for negligence.
Editor: What specific actions should the Leisure and Cultural Affairs Department instantly undertake to rectify this situation,and what role can the public play in fostering improved animal welfare?
Dr. Sharma: The Leisure and Cultural affairs Department must immediately launch a thorough and transparent inquiry into the Kowloon Park incident. This must lead to disciplinary action against anyone found to be responsible for neglect or cruelty. Together,a comprehensive training program for all staff must be implemented incorporating best practices in humane animal handling,emergency protocols,and animal welfare legislation. The department should create and publish a detailed list of standard operating procedures for all public aquariums and ponds, ensuring easy public access and monitoring. They must also implement enhanced dialogue strategies to inform the public of upcoming maintenance activities.
The public, meanwhile, is crucial. Citizens should be encouraged to report any suspected instances of neglect or cruelty through readily accessible and responsive channels, highlighting the need for clarity and strong public engagement. Further, public awareness campaigns can educate citizens about the importance of ethical animal care and empower them to become advocates for improved standards.
Editor: Beyond immediate responses, what long-term changes would you recommend to elevate animal welfare practices in Hong Kong’s public spaces?
Dr. Sharma: Long-term improvements necessitate strengthened animal welfare legislation with substantial penalties for neglect and cruelty, along with robust enforcement mechanisms. This requires a paradigm shift, fostering a culture that genuinely prioritizes animal well-being. We also need increased investment in animal rescue organizations, providing them with the resources necessary for rapid emergency response and community education. Additionally, improved collaboration between government agencies, animal welfare groups, and the public is essential for effective implementation and monitoring of regulations and practices. Regular inspections, audits, and transparent reporting provide critical oversight and ensure accountability.
Editor: What’s your ultimate message concerning the Kowloon Park incident and its broader implications?
Dr. Sharma: The Kowloon Park tragedy should serve as a powerful catalyst for change. It highlights that the welfare of animals in our public spaces is not a peripheral issue but a basic aspect of ethical obligation. We must collectively commit to preventing future incidents through robust systems, dedicated resources, comprehensive training, and, most importantly, a shared understanding that the well-being of all living creatures within our community is paramount. Only through proactive change and a commitment to transparency, accountability, and ongoing improvement can Hong Kong create truly humane and compassionate public spaces.
What are your thoughts on improving animal welfare standards in public spaces? Share your suggestions and insights in the comments below!