I assumed I did not personal a home, however I used to be hit with a heavy constructing tax – Maeil Enterprise Newspaper

Mr Kim, a non-resident who purchased the pre-sale simply two years in the past and was making ready the steadiness to maneuver into a brand new residence this fall, was stunned to listen to from his tax accountant that the development payment can be round 60 million gained. . Because the individual doesn’t have a house, the essential development tax fee (1-3%) was anticipated, however as an individual with 3 properties (non-negotiable space), 8% is utilized. The rationale why a heavy development tax fee was utilized is as a result of Mr. Kim had two properties when he purchased the best to promote, so the development tax was utilized based mostly on the variety of homes on the time of the contract of sale. Though he purchased the best to promote and get rid of the homes he already owned, he was categorized as a ‘a number of proprietor’ and tax was closely affected. Mr. Kim mentioned, “There may be an uproar as a result of new homes usually are not being offered, however I do not perceive why the insurance policies are nonetheless the identical as they had been earlier than.

Calls are rising to scrap the ‘punitive tax system’ which was launched 4 years in the past to stop hypothesis throughout the booming property market. Specialists say that the regulatory coverage launched by the earlier administration remains to be out there and has a damaging affect. Particularly, there are loud voices about reviewing the development tax, which is as much as 12%. Over the past authorities, because the switch tax guidelines had been accumulating, the ‘choose up tax’ appeared, which refers to tax accountants who gave up calculating switch tax, lately, the the phrase ‘development tax’ appeared within the complicated development tax guidelines.

The present housing development tax was created throughout the ‘July 10 Actual Property Measures’ in 2020. On the time, the Moon Jae-in administration raised the development tax fee for a number of owners, saying it could curb hypothesis . As well as, to stop hypothesis in pre-sale rights, occupancy rights and pre-sale rights acquired after August 12, 2020 have been included within the variety of homes.

It’s extra sophisticated if households are merged or separated after the pre-sale rights have been contracted. For instance, Mr. Lee, who signed a contract to promote in November 2021, joined his dad and mom in December 2022 on account of troublesome financial situations. This yr, Mr. When he purchased the pre-sale rights three years in the past, it was one homeless household. Nonetheless, as Lee’s dad and mom, who’re at the moment in the identical era, owned two homes on the time of Mr Lee’s right-to-sell contract, the three-home development tax fee is utilized. It is because the variety of homes is predicated on the identical family because the date of development of the home, and the variety of homes in that era is predicated on the variety of homes owned on the time of development of the best promote

An official from the Ministry of Public Administration and Safety defined, “After we purchase a home, we apply a development tax based mostly on the variety of homes on the time of acquiring the pre-sale proper house based mostly.”

Nonetheless, the Tax Tribunal got here up with a very completely different interpretation, growing confusion amongst finish customers. In January final yr, the Tax Tribunal determined that the native authorities’s resolution to use the variety of homes on the time of development to the best of pre-sale based mostly on the house throughout the development of homes was unfair. The petitioner, who owned one home as a single household when she received the best of pre-sale, received the home beneath the best of pre-sale after marriage. The applicant thought {that a} development tax can be imposed on 2 homes per family, however the native authorities imposed the heavy development tax pondering that the applicant had 3 homes as a result of the present partner was a proprietor of 1 home on the time the applicant obtained the best to promote. The applicant argued that as a result of he was single and dwelling alone when he obtained the best to promote, it was used as a two-family house, however the Tax Tribunal accepted the applicant’s argument.

Tax accountant Woo Byeong-tak mentioned, “If the interpretation of the Ministry of Public Administration and Safety and the Tax Tribunal are completely different, the taxpayer can personally request a correction and a refund of the development tax.”

Shin Bang-soo, a tax accountant, identified, “Many individuals is not going to make sure by utilizing the home quantity again,” and mentioned, “As a result of the legislation is so troublesome and complex, it’s only the confusion amongst clients continues to develop.”

The alternative case can also be absurd. If Mr. Park, who was of the identical era as his dad and mom who personal two properties, separated generations after signing the best of sale, he is not going to be topic to heavy development tax when he will get a home beneath the best of sale. It is because Mr. Park was a single household on the time he received the home, and the 2 homes owned by his dad and mom weren’t proven within the pre-sale contract.

Specialists say that uncommon taxes trigger uncommon responses from market individuals to keep away from taxes, which ends up in market turmoil.

Immediately, as the worth of pre-sale rights has elevated, persons are promoting pre-sale rights to acquaintances or members of the family after which shopping for them again, or giving them as items between {couples}, to keep away from heavy lifting payment. Even when an individual who owned a number of properties on the time of buy has a proper of pre-sale to promote the prevailing house when she or he has to pay the steadiness of the best of sale two or three years later that, the heavy lifting tax fee might be based mostly on. the previous multi-home proprietor is concerned. To keep away from this, the gross sales rights are resold to acquaintances who don’t personal a house after which purchased again after a sure interval. In some instances, a married couple can keep away from a heavy acquisition tax by giving up their proper of sale. An official within the presale business mentioned, “If the worth of presale rights has gone up, it could not be potential as a result of the switch payment is sophisticated, however nowadays, most have a damaging value of pre-sale rights in native areas. , so the timing of the contract is typically manipulated to scale back the acquisition payment.” The federal government promised to scale back penalty charges, however the evaluation of the legislation is stalled because of the opposition get together.

[이선희 기자]