Home » News » Fine Gael’s 11% VAT plan branded ‘laughable’ as parties trade insults over election pledges – The Irish Times

Fine Gael’s 11% VAT plan branded ‘laughable’ as parties trade insults over election pledges – The Irish Times

Fine Gael Promises Reduced VAT for Hospitality Ahead of Election

In a dramatic campaign kickoff, Fine Gael pledged to reduce the VAT rate for the hospitality sector to 11%, despite recent budgetary decisions that left the rate unchanged. This commitment was made by Taoiseach Simon Harris on a busy Saturday morning, just a day after the formal announcement of the upcoming general election set for November 29. The proposed VAT cut, aimed at invigorating struggling hospitality businesses, stands in stark contrast to the Coalition Government’s recent budget decisions that saw the rate restored to 13.5% after having been temporarily lowered to 9% during the pandemic.

Tackling the Hospitality Sector’s Concerns

Fine Gael’s proposal comes on the heels of substantial lobbying from the hospitality industry, which had advocated for a VAT reduction to 9%. The party’s promise to lower the VAT rate to 11% is seen as a compromise between industry demands and fiscal realities. "We recognize the challenges faced by the hospitality sector and are committed to supporting their recovery in the wake of the pandemic," said Harris during his canvassing efforts in Dublin.

However, the announcement has not been without controversy. Tánaiste Micheál Martin of Fianna Fáil responded with caution, stating that any VAT changes need to be examined comprehensively. He noted that reducing VAT for hospitality might lead to an increase in energy costs, which could subsequently affect gas and electricity prices for both businesses and homeowners.

Martin asserted, "If we are to make a reduction, we should consider going all the way to 9% rather than making a half-hearted adjustment that would cause other rates to rise." This sentiment reflects a broader concern regarding the potential ripple effects of such tax changes.

Opposition Critiques and Political Fallout

Opposition parties were quick to pounce on Fine Gael’s proposal, questioning its motivations and effectiveness. Sinn Féin’s finance spokesperson Pearse Doherty labeled the VAT pledge as “half-baked,” arguing it was hypocritical for Fine Gael to reject Sinn Féin’s earlier 9% VAT proposal. Labour leader Ivana Bacik expressed skepticism, stating, "The Fine Gael pledge rings hollow to me."

In response to criticism, Fine Gael asserted that their proposed 11% VAT cut would not negatively impact energy prices, countering claims made by their political rivals. According to party sources, both the new VAT rate for hospitality and the planned reversion of household utility VAT rates are designed to mitigate any adverse effects on consumers.

Economic Context and Future Implications

The backdrop to these political maneuvers is a critical moment for the hospitality industry in Ireland, which has been a significant economic driver yet continues to face multiple challenges in the post-pandemic landscape. The industry had hoped for relief in the form of a substantial VAT cut in the recent budget, but was met with disappointment when the rate remained unchanged.

“We’re looking for collaborative efforts to uplift the sector. An 11% VAT rate would provide much-needed support,” stated a representative of the hospitality sector, reflecting widespread industry sentiment.

Parties Navigate Election Strategy

As the general election campaign heats up, intricate negotiations regarding potential coalition partnerships are underway. Martin indicated concerns regarding entering a coalition with parties that may have differing economic philosophies. “Any party we partner with must support our economic model, which is crucial for employment, investment, and public services,” he explained.

Additionally, recent statements from Fianna Fáil include a commitment to renewable energy solutions, which have received mixed reactions from coalition partners like the Green Party. Ossian Smyth of the Green Party remarked on Fianna Fáil’s commitments to climate action, suggesting it is both welcome and overdue.

Your Voice in the Conversation

As the election approaches and various parties unveil their proposals, the conversation around the VAT rate for hospitality and other economic measures will only intensify. What are your thoughts on Fine Gael’s VAT proposal? Do you believe it will sufficiently address the challenges faced by the hospitality sector? Engage with us in the comments below or share your perspectives on social media. For more insights on the intersection of politics and economics, be sure to explore related articles on Shorty-News, and stay informed on updates regarding the general election.

For further reading, check out authoritative sources such as TechCrunch and Wired.


This article has been crafted to provide readers with comprehensive insights into the current political landscape as it relates to the hospitality VAT issue in Ireland, all while ensuring a neutral and informative tone. Let me know if you would like to adjust any sections or add more details on specific aspects.

Leave a Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.