Home » News » Error in the “Debate”: – I was surprised

Error in the “Debate”: – I was surprised

In NRK Debatten on 6 April, NRK presented figures for the proportion of children in the age group 0-17 years who have tested positive for covid-19 in weeks 5-10.

In a statement, the National Institute of Public Health emphasizes that NRK presented the figures as percentages of all tested in these weeks, and that it was wrong.

– They had received figures from the Reporting System for Infectious Diseases, MSIS, for the proportion of infected people in the age group 0-17 years in these groups, while Debatten presented these figures as a percentage.

Converted to a percentage, the figures will be a hundred times higher since, for example, a share of 0.05 corresponds to 5 percent, writes FHI.

– I was surprised to be presented live on TV for percentages I did not recognize. NRK’s ​​figures from FHI were unknown to me in advance and in general I think it is very important to always show both proportions and numbers, says Camilla Stoltenberg in FHI’s statement.

The national figures for the percentage of positive tests among children in these weeks can be read in FHI’s weekly reports (pages 8 and 9) for weeks 5-10 – where they are presented, writes FHI.

Reopening

The debate on NRK on 6 April was about, among other things, when Norwegian society can be reopened, and about the consequences of the corona measures for children and young people.

Early in the program, FHI director Stoltenberg and health director Bjørn Guldvog were confronted by program manager Fredrik Solvang, who claimed that the infection among the young people had been very low, writes Faktisk.no.

THE DEBATE: Fredrik Solvang confronts Camilla Stoltenberg and Bjørn Guldvog with the numbers.  Photo: Screenshot from NRK.no / Faktisk.no
THE DEBATE: Fredrik Solvang confronts Camilla Stoltenberg and Bjørn Guldvog with the numbers. Photo: Screenshot from NRK.no / Faktisk.no
view more

On a map behind Solvang, figures appeared that would show the proportion of young people between 0 and 9 years and between 10 and 17 who had taken a coronate test, who had tested positive from week 5 to week 10. The figures were distributed on a part of the country’s counties, and was according to Solvang taken from FHI.

And those were startling numbers. In Oslo, 0.05 per cent of those between 0 and 17 who had been tested had been diagnosed with the infection, according to NRK’s ​​figures. In Viken, the figure was lower, 0.04 per cent.

Confused health director

Health director Guldvog was stunned by the figures, and expressed that he thought they were too low. He did the right thing. In reality, the proportion of infected among the young was a hundred times higher than what Solvang claimed in weeks 5 to 10, writes Faktisk.no.

– Have we known this before? Solvang asks, aiming for the low numbers.

– No, I have not seen exactly this, and I am actually a little surprised by these numbers, so I think it is necessary to go…

– What are you wondering about? Solvang shoots in.

– That they are so low. In Oslo. I’m unsure of the numbers. I have to say that. So I would like to go on to check this afterwards, says Guldvog.

VACCINE: Pfizer announced on Wednesday 31 March that their corona vaccine has worked well on children between 12 and 15 years of age, which may be relevant to use in Norway. Host: Jeanette N. Vik / Dagbladet TV
view more

– Here it goes completely in ball

NRK has gone out and apologized for the error.

– In the Debate on Tuesday night, the wrong figures were given for the proportion of infected children and young people. It was stated that according to figures from FHI, only 0.05 percent of those tested were positive in a county like Oslo. The correct one should be five percent. The error occurred when shares were interpreted as percentages. NRK apologizes for the error, writes the state channel in a statement Tuesday night.

On his Instagram account, Fredrik Solvang has also apologized.

– Here it goes completely in ball. The debate has been damaged to confuse shares and percentages, so when I say, for example, that only 0.05% of those tested in Oslo had covid-19, that is the correct 5%, he writes and continues:

– FHI’s figures show that in weeks 5-10, the infection increased maximum among children and young people under the age of 17 to five percent in the worst affected county, Oslo. Sorry for the mistake! We will correct it in Kveldsnytt and on nrk.no.

Leave a Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.