Home » today » Health » Doctors no longer recommend ‘self-checks’ for breast cancer — here’s what to know

Doctors no longer recommend ‘self-checks’ for breast cancer — here’s what to know

Headline: Embracing Breast Self-Awareness: A Shift from Self-Exams for Early Detection

Nearly four years ago, Becca Brown, a 41-year-old resident of Burlington, Vermont, discovered a grape-sized lump during her nightly routine. The subsequent diagnosis revealed a fast-spreading cancer. Thanks to the lump’s early detection, Brown received prompt treatment and ultimately recovered. Today, she advocates for increased breast awareness, a notion that aligns with a growing trend recommending women to adopt a more intuitive understanding of their breast health, diverging from structured self-examinations.

The Transition from Self-Exams to Self-Awareness

In the past, medical professionals encouraged women at average risk for breast cancer to perform regular self-examinations, which typically involved a systematic approach to checking for changes in breast tissue. However, leading organizations like the U.S. Preventive Services Task Force, the American Cancer Society, and the American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists have shifted their recommendations from specific self-exams to what experts term "breast self-awareness."

Breast self-awareness emphasizes being attuned to how one’s breasts normally look and feel, rather than following a rigid examination routine. This new approach recognizes that many women can detect abnormalities based on their familiarity with their own body. A 2011 study published in the Journal of Women’s Health noted that around 25% of women detected breast tumors through deliberate self-checks, while an additional 18% discovered them by chance.

The Rationale Behind the Change

The rationale for moving away from routine breast self-exams is rooted in research suggesting that these exams have led to increased rates of false positives and unnecessary biopsies. Findings revealed that women who practiced traditional self-exams often underwent additional imaging tests that resulted in anxiety and undue stress when outcomes suggested the presence of cancer that was later determined to be benign.

Dr. Mary Gemignani, chief breast cancer surgeon at NYU Langone Health, expressed the perspective shift: “It’s not a doing; it’s more of a knowing. Most women know their bodies better than providers do, and any changes should be reported.”

Benefits of Breast Self-Awareness

Breast self-awareness allows for a more simplified, natural approach to monitoring breast health. Women are encouraged to check their breasts casually, incorporating this practice into their daily lives—perhaps while showering or dressing. Importantly, this self-awareness does not negate the necessity for regular screenings like mammograms or MRIs.

Dr. Mehra Golshan, deputy chief medical officer for surgical services at Smilow Cancer Hospital and Yale Cancer Center, noted the beneficial role of self-checking: "There are false positives and angst and anxiety that go into this, but I think most people are OK with that. Many patients would rather be safe than sorry."

Guidelines for Regular Screening

Despite the benefits of self-awareness, it’s critical to continue following established screening guidelines:

  • U.S. Preventive Services Task Force: Recommends biennial mammograms for women ages 40-74 at average risk.
  • American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists: Advocates for annual mammograms starting at age 40, continuing every one to two years until age 75.
  • American Cancer Society: Suggests annual mammograms for women ages 45-54 and biannual screenings thereafter.

For individuals with a family history of breast cancer or genetic predispositions, earlier and more frequent screenings may be necessary. Dr. Gemignani stresses the importance of consulting with healthcare providers regarding personal risk factors and considering genetic counseling.

Taking Precaution and Encouraging Action

Becca Brown highlights the importance of reporting any changes, no matter how small, to a medical professional. "It’s not enough to just find the lump," she cautions. "You actually have to go get it checked out and take action."

Engagement in breast self-awareness, supplemented with routine screenings, encourages early detection and treatment, ultimately saving lives.

Join the Conversation

How do you approach your breast health? Have you or someone you know found comfort in self-awareness practices? Share your thoughts in the comments below and consider discussing this vital topic with friends and family. By fostering awareness and sharing stories, we can contribute to a collective understanding and combat the fear associated with breast cancer diagnoses.

For further insights on health topics, visit Live Science and stay updated on the latest medical advancements.


This article underscores the essential role of personal health awareness and medical guidelines in the fight against breast cancer, empowering readers to take proactive steps in safeguarding their health. Together, we can promote a culture of diligence and resilience.

Leave a Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.