«It is necessary and appropriate to take a decisive position to ensure the immediate removal of the metal staircase, of enormous visual impact, which offends the history and beauty of the Certosa San Lorenzo in Padula. I would like to remind you that the Certosa di Padula was declared a World Heritage Site by UNESCO in 1998 and constitutes one of the greatest cultural and artistic attractions of our country. There are many exponents of culture, civil society and the territory, among which the European Landscape Observatory stands out, who have expressed themselves with very harsh words regarding this installation. The same former Minister of Culture, Gennaro Sangiuliano, spoke of disfigurement at the Certosa and subsequently the general director of the Museums, prof. Massimo Osannain response to a letter from the President of the European Landscape Observatory, the lawyer. Angelo Paladinospoke of its removal. Unfortunately, to this day, the staircase is still there making a terrible impression». He declared it Tommaso Pellegrinogroup leader of Italia Viva, during the question time held in the Chamber of the Campania Regional Council.
«It’s amazing – added Pellegrino – how the superintendence of cultural heritage often demonstrates great inflexibility in applying provisions that burden citizens, imposing the maintenance of structures that are sometimes even dilapidated and unsafe in the name of an alleged respect for the heritage, even when their state of degradation represents a real attack on decorum and safety. However, when the superintendency itself intervenes, aesthetic rigor and coherence with the cultural context seem to take a back seat. The installation of a structure so dissonant with the architectural harmony of the complex represents a mess, in clear contrast with those principles of protection and enhancement, which the superintendencies should support. Since the Certosa San Lorenzo di Padula is one of the main tourist attractions in Campania, also thanks to the numerous interventions of the Region aimed at promoting and enhancing the site, I hope for a timely removal of the metal staircase, restoring the Certosa the dignity it deserves” – he concluded councilor Pellegrino.
#Certosa #Padula #Pellegrino #Eliminate #scale #shame
–
How does the materiality of the modern staircase, specifically the choice of metal, contribute to the controversy surrounding its visual impact on the historical Certosa San Lorenzo?
## The Unsightly Staircase: A Discussion on Preservation vs. Modern Intervention
**Introduction:**
Welcome to World Today News. Today, we delve into a controversy surrounding the Certosa San Lorenzo in Padula, a UNESCO World Heritage site, and the recent installation of a modern metal staircase. Joining us are two distinguished guests:
* **Dr. Giulia Conti:** Art Historian and expert on Renaissance architecture, with particular focus on monastic complexes.
* **Mr. Marco Rossi:** Architect specializing in heritage conservation and urban regeneration.
**Section 1: The Visual Impact and Historical Context**
**(To Dr. Conti)** Dr. Conti, the article cites concerns about the staircase clashing with the historical integrity of the Certosa. Can you elaborate on the architectural significance of the Certosa and why this particular intervention has caused such controversy?
**(To Mr. Rossi)** Mr. Rossi, from an architectural perspective, how do you assess the visual impact of the staircase within the context of the Certosa’s design? Is there a way to balance modernization with respect for historical aesthetics?
**Section 2: The Role of Cultural Heritage Institutions**
**(To Dr. Conti)** The article mentions criticism directed at the superintendence of cultural heritage for allowing this installation. What are the ethical considerations involved in preserving historical sites while accommodating modern needs?
**(To Mr. Rossi)** Mr. Rossi, do you believe there are instances where modern interventions can complement historical structures, or should conservation efforts always prioritize strict adherence to original designs?
**Section 3: The Visitor Experience and Local Community Impact**
**(To Mr. Rossi)** Mr. Rossi, how might this staircase affect the visitor experience at the Certosa? Would it enhance accessibility or detract from the site’s overall ambiance?
**(To Dr. Conti)** Dr. Conti, as a UNESCO World Heritage site, the Certosa holds cultural significance for both Italy and the world. What role does the local community play in shaping decisions about the site’s future?
**Section 4: Balancing Preservation with Progress**
**(Both Guests)** Looking forward, how can we best balance the need to preserve historical sites with the desire for progress and modernity? What lessons can be learned from the Certosa case for future conservation efforts?
**Conclusion:**
Thank you, Dr. Conti and Mr. Rossi, for sharing your insights on this complex issue. The debate surrounding the Certosa staircase highlights the ongoing challenge of balancing preservation with adaptation in our ever-evolving world.
*(The interview closes with a call to action, encouraging viewers to engage in the discussion and share their own opinions on the topic.)*
