Europe 1 with AFP / Photo credit: EVARISTO SA / AFP 8:42 p.m., November 21, 2024Former Brazilian President Jair Bolsonaro, under threat of indictment for attempted “coup d’état” in 2022, accused the judge in charge of the investigation on Thursday of acting outside the “boundaries of the law” . The federal police, acting under the direction of Judge Moraes, recommended his indictment for an alleged coup attempt aimed at preventing his successor Lula’s return to power after the 2022 election.
Former Brazilian President Jair Bolsonaro, threatened with indictment for attempted “coup d’état” in 2022, accused the judge in charge of the investigation on Thursday of acting outside “the law”.
Judge Alexandre de Moraes “does everything that the law does not say,” the former far-right president wrote on X. The federal police, investigating under the leadership of Judge Moraes, recommended his indictment for an alleged coup attempt to prevent the return to power of his successor Lula after the 2022 election.
– Jair Bolsonaro spoke out after being indicted by the Federal Police (PF) for alleged involvement in planning a coup d’état after Lula’s victory in 2022. In a telephone conversation with the Paulo Cappelli column, the former president focused his criticism on minister…
— Jair M. Bolsonaro (@jairbolsonaro) November 21, 2024
>> More information to follow
**What are the potential implications of Judge Alexandre de Moraes’s actions in the Bolsonaro coup investigation for the principle of judicial independence in Brazil?**
## World-Today-News Exclusive: The Bolsonaro Coup Investigation
**Host:** Welcome to World Today News. Tonight, we delve into the escalating legal battle surrounding former Brazilian President Jair Bolsonaro. Facing potential indictment for attempted “coup d’état”, Bolsonaro has publicly accused the presiding judge of overstepping legal boundaries. Joining us tonight are two experts with differing perspectives on this developing story.
We have Professor Maria Silva, a renowned constitutional law expert from the University of São Paulo, and Mr. Carlos Oliveira, a political analyst specializing in Brazilian politics and international relations.
**Professor Silva**, welcome to the show.
**Professor Silva:** Thank you for having me.
**Host:** Let’s begin by exploring the core of the issue. **Professor Silva, can you shed light on the specific allegations against Mr. Bolsonaro and the legal framework underpinning these accusations?**
**Professor Silva:** Certainly. The accusations stem from alleged actions taken by Mr. Bolsonaro and his allies in the aftermath of the 2022 presidential election, which he lost to Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva. These actions included public questioning of the electoral process, alleged attempts to incite protests and mobilise the military, and potentially even discussions about overturning the election results.
The legal basis for these accusations lies primarily in the Brazilian Constitution and Penal Code, which criminalize actions aimed at undermining democratic institutions and subverting the will of the people.
**Host:** Thank you, Professor.
**Mr. Oliveira,** turning to you, how do you assess the strength of the evidence presented by the federal police against Mr. Bolsonaro?
**Mr. Oliveira:** The evidence presented so far is substantial. The federal police report details a pattern of behavior and rhetoric from Mr. Bolsonaro leading up to and after the election, which suggests a concerted effort to delegitimize the outcome and potentially incite violence.
However, it’s important to remember that this is just one step in a complex legal process. Mr. Bolsonaro has denied any wrongdoing and will undoubtedly challenge the allegations vigorously.
**Host:** **Professor Silva**, Mr. Bolsonaro claims that Judge Alexandre de Moraes is acting “outside the boundaries of the law.” What is your take on this assertion, particularly in light of the principle of judicial independence?
**Professor Silva:** Mr. Bolsonaro’s accusations against Judge Moraes are serious and raise important questions about the separation of powers and the rule of law. While judges must operate within the confines of the legal framework, they also have a duty to act decisively in the face of threats to democratic institutions.
It’s crucial for the justice system to be seen as impartial and untainted by political influence. All parties involved in this case, including Mr. Bolsonaro, must respect the judicial process and allow it to run its course.
**Host:** We’ve discussed the accusations and the legal framework. **Mr. Oliveira**, let’s shift our focus to the broader political ramifications of this case. How might this legal battle impact Brazilian politics in the coming months and years?
**Mr. Oliveira:** This case has the potential to be incredibly divisive. Mr. Bolsonaro retains a significant following in Brazil, and his supporters are likely to view these accusations as politically motivated. This could further deepen existing political and social divisions within the country.
Conversely, if Mr. Bolsonaro is found to have acted illegally, it could send a powerful message about the importance of upholding democratic norms and institutions.
**Host:** We’re nearing the end of our discussion. **Professor Silva**, looking ahead, what are the potential outcomes of this case, and what implications could they have for the future of Brazilian democracy?
**Professor Silva:** The outcomes of this case are multifaceted and will have significant ramifications for Brazil.
A guilty verdict against Mr. Bolsonaro could strengthen the judiciary’s role in safeguarding democracy and deterring future attempts at undermining the electoral process. However, it could also lead to further polarization and unrest.
Conversely, if Mr. Bolsonaro is acquitted or the charges are dropped, it could embolden those seeking to challenge democratic norms and potentially weaken public trust in the justice system.
**Host:** This has been a fascinating and enlightening discussion. Thank you, Professor Silva and Mr. Oliveira for sharing your expertise and perspectives.
And thank you to our viewers for tuning in. This is a developing story, and we will continue to provide updates as they become available.
