Hamburg – Convicts will be happy about this news: 30 convicted criminals are allowed to go home immediately – because the cells in Hamburg’s prisons are overcrowded! And: Other criminals are also expected to be released in the next six months.
According to BILD information, there is a circular from the public prosecutor’s office to the police commissioners in Hamburg. It calls on officers to stop arresting men who have an arrest warrant because of unpaid fines.
The judicial authority says: “No new replacement prisoners will be accepted for the time being.” The sentences have not been deleted, but should be enforced at a later date.
This means that the police can only start looking for criminals who have gone underground again later.
The Hamburg remand prison at Holstenglacis, there are 482 detention places (as of 2018)
This unusual decision benefits, for example, fare evaders who were sentenced to a fine but did not pay it. Also: shoplifters, drivers who were behind the wheel without a license, but also thugs.
Anyone who does not pay usually has to serve their fine as a so-called “substitute prison sentence”; the number of days is determined in the judgment. The fact that someone like that is allowed to go home early only happens at Christmas.
Read also
“As in other federal states, the occupancy situation in the prisons in Hamburg is very tense,” says the judicial authority. Therefore, the criminals could not be housed in other prisons in Germany. Postponement and interruption of the execution of sentences have already proven their worth during Corona and the European Football Championship.
“A testament to poverty for the senator”
Sharp criticism comes from the Hamburg police. Thomas Jungfer, state chairman of the German Police Union (DPolG): “It is a disgrace for Justice Senator Anna Gallina and her authority that they cannot provide enough detention places. Now we have to let people who have been booked for arrest go again. It couldn’t be more miserable.”
**PAA:** What are the potential long-term social and economic consequences of relying on prison releases as a temporary solution to overcrowding, rather than addressing the underlying causes?
## World Today News: Interview on Hamburg Prison Overcrowding
**Guests:**
* **Professor Anna Schmidt:** Criminologist and expert on prison systems.
* **Officer Michael Weber:** Representative of the Hamburg Police Union.
**Introduction:**
Welcome to World Today News. Today we’re discussing the recent announcement from Hamburg’s judicial authority regarding the release of approximately 30 convicted criminals due to overcrowded prisons. We’re joined by Professor Anna Schmidt, a leading criminologist, and Officer Michael Weber, representing the Hamburg Police Union.
**Section 1: The Overcrowding Issue:**
* **Interviewer:** Professor Schmidt, the article cites prison overcrowding as the primary reason for this decision. Can you elaborate on the factors contributing to this problem in Hamburg and across Germany?
* **Interviewer:** Officer Weber, the police union has voiced strong criticism regarding this decision. Can you explain the concerns from a law enforcement perspective? How does this impact your ability to maintain public safety?
**Section 2: Ethical and Legal Implications:**
* **Interviewer:** Professor Schmidt, releasing individuals convicted of crimes, even temporarily, raises ethical questions. What are the potential consequences of this decision for victims and the wider community?
* **Interviewer:** Mr. Weber, some argue that punishments should be served regardless of prison capacity. What are your thoughts on the balance between upholding the law and addressing overcrowding?
**Section 3: Long-Term Solutions:**
* **Interviewer:** Professor Schmidt, what are some potential long-term solutions to address prison overcrowding? Are there alternative sentencing options that could be implemented?
* **Interviewer:** Officer Weber, what measures would the Police Union like to see the Hamburg government take to prevent similar situations in the future?
**Section 4: Broader Societal Impact:**
* **Interviewer:** This situation highlights a larger conversation about criminal justice reform. Professor Schmidt, how can we move towards a more effective and humane system that prioritizes rehabilitation and prevention?
* **Interviewer:** Mr. Weber, what role can community organizations and social services play in mitigating the factors that contribute to crime?
**Conclusion:**
* **Interviewer:** Thank you both for sharing your valuable insights on this complex issue. The release of convicts due to overcrowding raises crucial questions about justice, public safety, and the future of the prison system. We hope this discussion has shed light on the various perspectives involved and encourages a continued dialog on finding sustainable solutions.
