South Africa Considers Tax Cuts,Local Production to Lower Smartphone Costs
Table of Contents
Published: Febuary 27,2025
South Africa is exploring measures to make smartphones more affordable for its citizens. Mobile operators MTN and Vodacom are advocating for lower taxes and increased local production. This call to action follows a collaborative workshop hosted by the Department of Communications and Digital Technologies (DCDT), in partnership with the World Bank and GSMA, a non-profit representing mobile network operators globally. The workshop addressed the challenges of smartphone affordability and sought solutions from both public and private sector stakeholders.
GSMA presented several suggestions during the workshop,focusing on how stakeholders in the South African smartphone market could work together to decrease the price of smartphones. Following this presentation, MyBroadband reached out to South Africa’s mobile operators to gather their perspectives on potential solutions.
A Vodacom spokesperson emphasized the impact of high import duties and taxes, along with currency fluctuations, on smartphone prices. Firstly, lowering import duties and taxes (e.g. luxury goods duties and VAT) on smartphones can substantially reduce retail prices, making them more affordable for consumers,
Vodacom stated.
Vodacom also highlighted the potential benefits of local manufacturing.Encouraging local manufacturing with specific benefits and regulation can also play a crucial role. in addition, implementing subsidies, such as the global service fund and sector-specific policies, can help facilitate the flow of affordable smartphones, especially entry-level models.
MTN SA echoed Vodacom’s sentiments regarding tax reduction and local production. However, they also pointed to logistical and distribution costs as contributing factors. To reduce these costs and make smartphones more accessible, measures such as reducing import taxes and encouraging local assembly or manufacturing shoudl be encouraged,
MTN said.
MTN further suggested that increased competition could drive prices down. Moreover, greater competition in the market, supported by the entry of new brands and improved mobile operator offerings, could drive prices down.
the import duties referenced by both networks pertain to the luxury goods or ad valorem duty. Communications Minister Solly Malatsi has been a vocal advocate for its removal. In South Africa, ad valorem is a tax applied to products considered luxury items, including motor vehicles, electronic equipment, and cosmetics. A flat rate of 9% is currently applied to technology products.
GSMA has argued that while cutting this duty may lead to a short-term decrease in tax revenue, it would ultimately increase penetration in the long run, boosting revenue across the entire mobile sector. This is notably relevant given South Africa’s plan to phase out 2G and 3G networks in the coming years, rendering phones using these technologies obsolete.
A leaked document from the South African Revenue Service revealed that Finance Minister Enoch Godongwana had considered introducing a threshold for ad valorem duty, exempting cheaper smartphones from the tax. However, his budget speech was delayed until March 12, 2025, due to a dispute over a proposed increase in the VAT rate from 15% to 17%.
Increased Smartphone Competition
Both Vodacom and MTN emphasized the importance of increased competition in the smartphone market to drive down prices. Currently, Samsung dominates the market with a 52.57% market share,according to StatCounter GlobalStats.
Samsung surpassed Nokia in December 2014. Nokia’s market share dropped from approximately 68% two years prior to roughly 27%.
Apple currently holds the second position with 16.6%, followed by Huawei at 10.71%, and Xiaomi at 3.49%.
Oppo South Africa, a Chinese smartphone manufacturer with a 3.29% market share, notes that the current market landscape can be challenging for new entrants. Consumers prioritise measurable technical specifications, such as battery life, camera resolutions, and storage capacity,
Oppo said.
Oppo also highlighted the financial constraints faced by many South African households. As of the strain on the average household purse, it noted that 85% of devices priced above R3,000 are sold through post-paid contracts, as consumers can’t afford to buy these devices in cash. On the other hand, it added that 80% of all sales occur in the prepaid segment.
The discussions surrounding tax cuts, local production, and increased competition signal a concerted effort to address smartphone affordability in South Africa. With the planned phasing out of 2G and 3G networks, ensuring access to affordable smartphones is crucial for bridging the digital divide and enabling broader participation in the digital economy. The upcoming budget speech on March 12, 2025, may provide further clarity on the government’s plans to address these challenges.
south africas Smartphone Struggle: Can Tax Cuts & Local Production Bridge the Digital Divide?
“The cost of smartphones in South Africa is a significant barrier to digital inclusion, preventing millions from accessing vital online services and opportunities.”
Interviewer: Dr. Anya Sharma,welcome to World-Today-News.com.your expertise in african economic development and telecommunications policy is invaluable as we delve into South Africa’s efforts to make smartphones more affordable. Could you begin by outlining the core challenges hindering smartphone accessibility in the country?
Dr. Sharma: Absolutely! The challenge of affordable smartphone access in South africa is multifaceted.Its not simply a matter of price, but rather a complex interplay of economic factors. High import duties and taxes, as highlighted by Vodacom and MTN, significantly inflate retail costs. Furthermore, currency fluctuations create price volatility, making it difficult for consumers and businesses to plan. This impacts affordability directly, but also limits access to the innovative technologies that can transform the lives of many. Beyond these financial hurdles, another is the issue of local assembly and supply chain development. Without robust local manufacturing, the nation relies heavily on imports, making it vulnerable to global market shocks and potentially limiting market penetration to only affordable alternatives.
Interviewer: The article mentions the potential benefits of reducing import duties, particularly the ad valorem tax on luxury goods. What’s your viewpoint on the feasibility and impact of such a measure?
Dr. Sharma: Lowering import duties, including the ad valorem tax on smartphones, is a crucial step towards enhancing affordability. While there’s a valid concern about potential short-term revenue losses, as GSMA points out, the long-term economic benefits—increased smartphone penetration and a stimulated mobile sector—far outweigh these concerns. Reduced import taxes directly translate to lower consumer prices, driving demand and boosting economic activity across various sectors. This is especially critical in light of the planned phasing out of 2G and 3G networks; citizens will need affordable 4G or 5G devices to remain connected. Think of the ripple effects: increased access to facts, online education, digital financial services, and job opportunities will generate economic value for the nation.
Interviewer: Local manufacturing is presented as another key solution. What are the realistic challenges and potential benefits of fostering a domestic smartphone manufacturing industry in South Africa?
Dr. Sharma: Developing robust local smartphone manufacturing capabilities addresses several important issues.It reduces reliance on imports, creating economic resilience in volatile markets. Plus, we can foster local job creation, technology transfer, and expertise development, reducing the brain drain and encouraging higher technological skillsets among workers. Though, achieving this requires strategic governmental investment, clear regulatory frameworks that incentivize both domestic and foreign investment in the manufacturing sector, and dedicated programs focusing on the training of individuals for the higher-skill roles required for a advanced high-tech manufacturing economy.
interviewer: The role of competition is also highlighted. How can promoting greater competition among smartphone manufacturers contribute to lower prices and better products in the south African market?
Dr. Sharma: Increased competition fosters innovation and price reductions.The current market dominance by samsung, while reflecting its successful market position, may not necessarily reflect the best options for consumers and the most successful growth of the market sector over time. Encouraging new entrants, particularly those offering more budget-friendly and cost-effective smartphones adapted to local needs, is essential. This will drive down prices and encourage companies to offer better value for money, forcing existing giants such as Samsung to adapt and offer attractive, competitive pricing and features. Governments can facilitate this by streamlining regulations for new market entrants, promoting fair competition policies, and potentially investigating anti-trust measures amongst existing industry leaders.
Interviewer: what are some specific policy recommendations you would offer to the South African government to effectively address smartphone affordability?
Dr. Sharma: To effectively tackle and address smartphone affordability, I recommend a holistic approach:
reduce import duties and taxes: Target tariffs on smartphones explicitly, not only the ad valorem taxes on higher-end models.
Invest in local manufacturing: Provide incentives, tax breaks, and infrastructure support for domestic manufacturing and supply chain development.
Promote competition: Ease regulations for new entrants, enforce antitrust regulations where appropriate, enhance oversight practices, and potentially consider government procurement policies to promote competition amongst sellers.
Expand financial inclusion: Develop innovative financing schemes and subsidies to make smartphones accessible to low-income consumers. Consider innovative public-private partnerships.
* Invest in digital literacy: Ensure that there is sufficient educational and training programs for citizens to take advantage of owning technology.
Interviewer: Thank you, Dr. Sharma, for your insights. This thorough approach seems essential. Your expertise clearly highlights the need for a multi-pronged strategy – combining fiscal policies, investment in infrastructure, and competitive market mechanisms – to truly bridge the digital divide in South Africa.
Final Thought: The affordability challenge concerning smartphones in South Africa isn’t just about economics; it’s about inclusion, access, and opportunity.Let’s discuss this critical issue further – share your thoughts in the comments below or on social media using #digitalinclusionsa.