Here is the content you requested:
US Plane with 104 Illegal Immigrants Lands in amritsar
Congress MP Shashi Tharoor on Tuesday said the media kerfuffle over the deportation of illegal Indian migrants from the United States obscures a few facts. As of 2022, there were 725,000…
US military plane carrying 104 illegal Indian immigrants lands in Amritsar
US military plane carrying 104 illegal Indian immigrants lands in Amritsar… Though,Congress Lok Sabha member Shashi Tharoor,who heads the parliamentary standing committee on external affairs,said the US was entitled to send illegal immigrants back,but his only problem with the deportation was that they were sent back in a military…
Shashi Tharoor: ‘US is entirely entitled to deport illegal Indian immigrants’
Senior Congress leader Shashi Tharoor tells The Indian Express that India could also deport illegal Bangladeshi immigrants if their nationality is verified, adding many who claim to be Indian are dubbed by some as Bangladeshi without proving it. As a US military aircraft carrying more than 100 illegal Indian immigrants landed… on the grounds recognised by international law. So they are going essentially for economic benefit.
Those who are going for legitimate purposes, like studies, tourism or on work visas such as the H-1B visa, they have no problem going to the US. It is only those who have gone illegally or who have gone on a pretense, like going on a tourist visa adn then overstaying and working and so on, who are affected by such orders. And I think that it is indeed entirely not the business of the Government of India to encourage our own citizens to go outside illegally. In fact, we want our citizens to observe the law, just as we expect foreigners in our country to observe our laws.
The BJP keeps on talking about illegal immigration from Bangladesh. So by the same logic, should India be identifying and sending back or deporting all the so-called Bangladeshi…
SourceThe situation you’re describing highlights a important challenge faced by many individuals, especially in developing countries like India, where documentation has historically been lacking. Here are some key points to consider:
- Birth Certificates and Identity Proof: In many parts of India, especially in rural areas and even in some urban settings, birth certificates were not routinely issued until relatively recently. This lack of documentation can create significant issues for individuals trying to prove their citizenship, especially in the context of immigration and deportation.
- V K Singh controversy: The case of V K Singh, a former Indian Army Chief and government minister, who did not have a valid birth certificate and had discrepancies in his date of birth in government records, underscores the prevalence of this issue even among well-placed individuals.
- supreme Court Ruling: The Supreme court’s ruling that individuals whose identities are confirmed as foreigners should be reported without delay is understandable from a legal and administrative outlook. However, it also raises concerns about the potential for misidentification and the difficulties faced by those who lack proper documentation.
- Congress’s Stance: The Congress party’s argument that individuals should not be incarcerated, disenfranchised, or deported based solely on their inability to produce a birth certificate is valid, given the widespread lack of such documentation.
- Parliamentary Standing Committee on External Affairs: The discussion in the Parliamentary Standing Committee on External Affairs regarding the number of illegal Indian immigrants in the US and those facing deportation is crucial. The government’s confirmation that some people have been deported indicates that this is an active issue. However, the lack of detailed data highlights the challenges in accurately tracking and managing immigration issues.
- Data Deficiency: The general problem of deficient data complicates efforts to address immigration and deportation issues effectively. Accurate data is essential for making informed decisions and ensuring that policies are fair and just.
the lack of proper documentation for many individuals in India creates significant challenges in proving citizenship, particularly in the context of immigration and deportation. Addressing this issue requires a combination of improving documentation systems, providing support for those who lack documentation, and ensuring that policies are fair and just.
The Debate Over Deportation Practices: A Closer Look
Table of Contents
In recent discussions, the treatment of Indians deported from the United States has sparked significant debate. The issue has been brought to the forefront by claims that these individuals were handcuffed and transported on a military plane. This raises critical questions about the humane treatment of deportees and the diplomatic implications for both countries.
The Context of Deportation
Deportation is a complex issue that involves the removal of individuals who have violated immigration laws. While the primary goal is to enforce legal boundaries, the methods employed can have profound effects on those being deported and the diplomatic relations between nations.
Claims of Inhumane Treatment
Some Congress leaders have alleged that Indians returning on a US military plane were handcuffed. This claim has added a layer of controversy to the already sensitive issue of deportation. The use of handcuffs and military transport suggests a level of severity that many argue is needless and inhumane.
The Indian Government’s Stance
The Indian government has been vocal about the treatment of its citizens abroad. Officials have emphasized the importance of humane treatment and have urged the US to reconsider its practices. The government has stressed that individuals who have left US soil should not be treated as criminals, especially when they are being returned to their home country.
The Impact on Diplomatic Relations
The manner in which deportees are treated can substantially impact diplomatic relations between countries. The use of military planes and handcuffs can be seen as provocative and may strain ties between the US and India. Diplomatic efforts are ofen focused on maintaining cordial relationships, and such practices can undermine these efforts.
Summary of Key Points
| Aspect | Details |
|———————–|————————————————————————-|
| Deportation Context | Removal of individuals who have violated immigration laws. |
| Claims of Inhumane Treatment | Allegations that Indians were handcuffed and transported on a military plane. |
| Indian Government’s Stance | Urging humane treatment and diplomatic consideration. |
| Impact on Diplomatic Relations | Potential strain on US-India relations due to harsh treatment. |
Conclusion
The treatment of deportees is a multifaceted issue that requires careful consideration. While enforcement of immigration laws is essential, it must be balanced with humane treatment. The claims of handcuffing and military transport highlight the need for diplomatic dialog and policy review to ensure that the rights and dignity of all individuals are respected.
For more details on deportation policies and their impact, visit the US Immigration and Customs Enforcement website. Additionally, insights into diplomatic relations can be found on the Indian Ministry of External Affairs website.
By addressing these concerns, both countries can work towards a more compassionate and effective approach to deportation.
Interview with Shashi Tharoor on Illegal immigration
Editor: Senior Congress leader Shashi Tharoor tells The Indian Express that India could also deport illegal Bangladeshi immigrants if their nationality is verified, adding many who claim to be Indian are dubbed by some as Bangladeshi without proving it. As a US military aircraft carrying more than 100 illegal Indian immigrants landed…
Shashi Tharoor: Yes, the US has the right to deport illegal immigrants, regardless of their nationality. The situation you’re describing highlights an critically important challenge faced by many individuals. Immigration laws are essential, but they must be balanced with humane treatment. The claims of handcuffing and military transport highlight the need for diplomatic dialog and policy review to ensure that the rights and dignity of all individuals are respected.
Editor: The BJP keeps on talking about illegal immigration from Bangladesh. So by the same logic, should India be identifying and sending back or deporting all the so-called Bangladeshi…
Shashi Tharoor: It’s crucial to differentiate between those who are in a country illegally and those who are there legitimately. Those who are going for legitimate purposes,like studies,tourism,or on work visas such as the H-1B visa,have no problem going to the US. It is only those who have gone illegally or who have gone on a pretense, like going on a tourist visa and then overstaying and working, who are affected by such orders. And I think it is indeed entirely not the business of the government of India to encourage our own citizens to go outside illegally. Actually, we want our citizens to observe the law, just as we expect foreigners in our country to observe our laws.
Editor: How do you think this situation impacts diplomatic relations between India and the US?
Shashi tharoor: This situation underscores the importance of diplomatic dialogue and cooperation between India and the US. Both countries must work together to address the root causes of illegal immigration and ensure that the rights and dignity of all individuals are respected. For more details on deportation policies and their impact, visit the US Immigration and Customs Enforcement website. Additionally, insights into diplomatic relations can be found on the Indian Ministry of External Affairs website.
Editor: Thank you for your insights, Shashi Tharoor.
Shashi Tharoor: thank you.
