Revolutionizing Rock Climbing: How Machine Learning is Creating a Fairer Grading System
Table of Contents
Rock climbing has surged in popularity since its debut at teh 2020 Tokyo Olympics, but one challenge remains unresolved: how to objectively grade the difficulty of climbing routes. A groundbreaking study by researchers at the University of New Hampshire (UNH) has introduced a novel solution—leveraging machine and deep learning techniques to create a standardized grading system that promotes inclusivity, accuracy, and accessibility for climbers of all skill levels.
Published in the journal Frontiers in Sport and Active Living, the study highlights the potential of natural language processing (NLP) and route-centric data analysis to eliminate biases and inconsistencies in route grading.”Rock climbing’s popularity as a recreational sport is growing dramatically,” says Blaise O’Mara,a graduate student at UNH and lead author of the study. “Reporting the objective grade of a climbing route is critical in the climbing community, but the challenge has been in how to set a uniform grade that applies to all skill levels.”
The Challenge of Subjective Grading
Currently, rock climbing route difficulty is often steadfast by personal judgment, leading to inconsistencies and bias. Commercial climbing gyms, in particular, require objectivity to ensure routes are attainable for climbers of all levels. Though, without an official standard, grading remains a subjective process.The UNH study sought to address this issue by exploring how machine learning could streamline route setting. Researchers categorized machine learning techniques into three approaches: route-centric,climber-centric,and path-finding.
- Route-centric: Focused on analyzing route features such as hold types, movements between holds, and sequences.
- Climber-centric: Used wearable sensors to track metrics like electromyography and acceleration, while also considering past climbing performances.
- Path-finding: Combined qualities from both route-centric and climber-centric approaches.
According to MD Shaad Mahmud, associate professor of electrical and computer engineering at UNH, “The route-centric approach focused on analyzing route features such as hold types, movements between holds and sequences, while the climber-centric approach involved using wearable sensors to track metrics like electromyography and acceleration and looked at past climbing performances. The path-finding approach combined qualities from the other approaches.”
The Winning Approach: Route-Centric Data and NLP
The study found that the route-centric method, combined with natural language processing, achieved the greatest granularity accuracy of 84.7%. This approach analyzed route features and fed the data through an NLP algorithm, offering a more objective method for rating difficulty.
“through our research,we seek to address how climbing gyms can integrate machine and deep learning systems to streamline route setting and eliminate route difficulty bias,” said mahmud.
The researchers believe that future success in determining rock climbing difficulty will rely on route-centric data extracted with computer vision and processed through NLP algorithms. As machine learning and deep learning methods continue to evolve, they may solve the pervasive grading bias problem in rock climbing.
Key Findings at a Glance
| Approach | Focus | Accuracy |
|———————–|—————————————————————————|————–|
| Route-Centric | Analyzes hold types, movements, and sequences | 84.7% |
| Climber-Centric | Uses wearable sensors and past performance data | N/A |
| Path-Finding | Combines route-centric and climber-centric qualities | N/A |
The Future of Rock Climbing Grading
As rock climbing continues to grow, the demand for a consistent and objective grading system becomes increasingly vital. The UNH study offers a promising solution, paving the way for a fairer and more inclusive climbing experience.
With further advancements in machine learning and deep learning, the climbing community may soon have a standardized system that eliminates bias and ensures accuracy for climbers of all levels.
This work was supported by the N.H. Agricultural Experiment Station CREATE grant (11HN37).
—
What are your thoughts on using machine learning to grade climbing routes? Share your opinions in the comments below!
Revolutionizing Rock Climbing: How Machine Learning is Creating a Fairer Grading System
Rock climbing has surged in popularity as its debut at the 2020 Tokyo Olympics, but one challenge remains unresolved: how to objectively grade the difficulty of climbing routes.A groundbreaking study by researchers at the University of New Hampshire (UNH) has introduced a novel solution—leveraging machine and deep learning techniques to create a standardized grading system that promotes inclusivity, accuracy, and accessibility for climbers of all skill levels. in this interview, we speak with Dr. Shaad Mahmud,Associate Professor of Electrical and Computer Engineering at UNH,to delve into the details of this innovative approach and its potential impact on the climbing community.
The Challenge of Subjective Grading
Senior Editor (SE): dr. Mahmud, thank you for joining us. The study highlights the subjectivity in current climbing route grading. Can you elaborate on why this is a significant issue, especially in commercial climbing gyms?
Dr. Shaad Mahmud (SM): Absolutely. Subjective grading is a major concern because it leads to inconsistencies and biases. In commercial climbing gyms, where climbers of all levels come to train and enjoy the sport, it’s crucial that routes are accurately graded. When grades are inconsistent, it can be frustrating for beginners and demotivating for experienced climbers.Our goal was to find a way to standardize grading so that it’s fair and accessible for everyone.
Exploring Machine Learning Approaches
SE: Your study explored three machine learning approaches: route-centric, climber-centric, and path-finding. Could you break down thes methods and why the route-centric approach stood out?
SM: Certainly. The route-centric approach focuses on analyzing the physical characteristics of a route—things like hold types, movements between holds, and sequences. The climber-centric approach uses wearable sensors to track climbers’ metrics,such as muscle activity and acceleration,and considers their past performance. The path-finding approach combines elements from both. What we found is that the route-centric method, when combined with natural language processing (NLP), achieved the highest accuracy at 84.7%. This is because it directly analyzes route features, making it more objective and reliable.
The Role of Natural Language Processing
SE: NLP seems to be a key component in this system. how does it enhance the route-centric approach?
SM: NLP plays a critical role in interpreting and analyzing the data we gather from climbing routes. For example, when we describe a route’s features—like the types of holds or the difficulty of certain movements—NLP helps us process that details systematically. It allows us to create a standardized language for grading, which reduces ambiguity and human bias.Essentially,it’s about translating qualitative descriptions into quantitative data that machine learning algorithms can work with.
The Future of rock Climbing Grading
SE: What do you see as the next steps for implementing this technology in the climbing community?
SM: The next phase involves refining the algorithms and testing them in real-world climbing gyms. We’re also exploring how computer vision can be integrated to automatically analyze route features without manual input. Over time, as the technology evolves, I believe we’ll see a widespread adoption of machine learning-based grading systems. This will not onyl improve the climbing experience but also make the sport more inclusive and welcoming to newcomers.
Conclusion
SE: Dr. Mahmud, thank you for sharing your insights. It’s clear that machine learning has the potential to revolutionize how we grade climbing routes, making the sport more accessible and fair for climbers of all skill levels. We look forward to seeing this technology in action!
SM: Thank you! It’s an exciting time for the climbing community, and I’m hopeful that these advancements will benefit everyone involved.
