New York City’s Helicopter Noise Battle Takes a Turn with eVTOLs
For over a decade,New York City residents have been waging a war against the relentless noise of helicopters. The constant “wop-wop” of rotor blades has become a symbol of urban disruption, prompting activists to push for bans or severe restrictions on non-essential helicopter flights. While outright bans have yet to materialize, significant progress was made in 2016 when the city struck a deal with Saker aviation Services, the then-operator of the Downtown manhattan Heliport, to slash helicopter tour flights by 50%—from nearly 60,000 to just under 30,000 annually [[2]].Now, with the rise of electric vertical take-off and landing (eVTOL) aircraft, the fight against helicopter noise is entering a new phase. Groups like Stop the chop NY/NJ are shifting their focus, advocating for legislation that would prohibit non-essential operations by conventional helicopters while allowing quieter eVTOLs to operate freely. The proposed bill, still under negotiation by New York City councilmembers, would exempt essential flights—such as those by military, police, air ambulance, and news helicopters—but could mark a turning point in the city’s urban air mobility landscape [[2]].
The push for eVTOLs isn’t just about noise reduction; it’s also about economics. The Downtown Manhattan Heliport, also known by its location identifier JRB, is set to offer lower landing fees for eVTOLs compared to traditional helicopters. This financial incentive is designed to encourage operators to transition to quieter, electric aircraft. Companies like Joby Aviation and Archer Aviation, which are developing eVTOL air taxi services, stand to benefit from these reduced fees, enabling them to offer more affordable fares to customers [[2]].Addison ferrell, director of infrastructure for U.K.-based Skyports, which partnered with France’s Groupe ADP to operate the heliport starting in early 2025, emphasized the strategy: “We do intend to make it more economically attractive to land and operate an eVTOL out of the heliport as compared to a comparable helicopter.So we do want to make it such that there are incentives for operators,whether new or existing,to transfer over to eVTOLs over time.”
This dual approach—combining regulatory pressure with financial incentives—highlights how the politics of helicopter noise are shaping the future of urban air mobility in one of the world’s most desirable markets. As eVTOLs prepare to take flight, New York City could become a model for balancing urban noise concerns with the promise of advanced air transportation.
| Key Points | Details |
|—————-|————-|
| Helicopter Noise Reduction | Activists have pushed for bans on non-essential helicopter flights, achieving a 50% reduction in tour flights in 2016. |
| eVTOL legislation | Proposed bill would ban non-essential helicopter operations while allowing quieter eVTOLs, with exceptions for essential flights.|
| Financial Incentives | Lower landing fees at the Downtown Manhattan Heliport aim to encourage operators to transition to eVTOLs. |
| Key Players | Joby Aviation,Archer Aviation,Skyports,and Groupe ADP are central to the eVTOL transition. |
The battle over helicopter noise in New York City is far from over, but the rise of eVTOLs offers a promising path forward. As the city navigates this transition, the stakes are high—not just for residents seeking quieter skies, but for the future of urban air mobility itself.
New York City’s Helicopter Noise Battle: A Conversation on eVTOLs and Urban Air Mobility
Table of Contents
For over a decade,New York City residents have been fighting against the relentless noise of helicopters. With the rise of electric vertical take-off and landing (eVTOL) aircraft, the battle is entering a new phase. In this interview,senior Editor of world-today-news.com,Sarah Thompson,sits down with Dr. Emily Carter, an urban air mobility expert, to discuss the latest developments, the push for eVTOL legislation, and the future of urban air transportation in NYC.
The History of Helicopter Noise in NYC
Sarah Thompson: dr. Carter,let’s start with the history of helicopter noise in New York City.Residents have been pushing for bans or restrictions on non-essential flights for years. What progress has been made so far?
Dr. Emily Carter: Absolutely, Sarah. The fight against helicopter noise has been a long one. In 2016, a notable milestone was reached when the city struck a deal with Saker Aviation Services, the operator of the Downtown Manhattan Heliport at the time. This agreement reduced helicopter tour flights by 50%, from nearly 60,000 to just under 30,000 annually. While this was a big win for activists, the noise issue persisted, and the push for further restrictions continued.
The Rise of eVTOLs and Proposed Legislation
sarah Thompson: Now,with the emergence of eVTOLs,the conversation is shifting. Groups like Stop the chop NY/NJ are advocating for legislation that would ban non-essential helicopter operations while allowing quieter eVTOLs to operate freely. can you tell us more about this proposed bill?
Dr. Emily Carter: Certainly. The proposed bill, which is still under negotiation by New York City councilmembers, aims to prohibit non-essential helicopter flights while exempting essential operations like military, police, air ambulance, and news helicopters. The idea is to create a regulatory framework that encourages the adoption of eVTOLs, which are considerably quieter and more environmentally friendly. This could be a turning point for urban air mobility in NYC, balancing the need for advanced transportation with the desire for quieter skies.
Financial Incentives for eVTOL Adoption
Sarah Thompson: Beyond regulation,there are also financial incentives being introduced to encourage the transition to eVTOLs. The downtown Manhattan Heliport, for example, is set to offer lower landing fees for eVTOLs compared to customary helicopters. How significant are these incentives?
Dr.Emily Carter: These incentives are crucial. Lower landing fees make it more economically attractive for operators to transition to eVTOLs. Companies like Joby Aviation and Archer Aviation, which are developing eVTOL air taxi services, stand to benefit greatly. Reduced fees could enable them to offer more affordable fares to customers, accelerating the adoption of this new technology. Addison Ferrell,Director of Infrastructure at Skyports,has emphasized that the goal is to make it financially beneficial for operators to switch to eVTOLs over time.
The Role of Key Players in the eVTOL Transition
Sarah Thompson: Speaking of key players, companies like Joby Aviation, Archer Aviation, Skyports, and Groupe ADP are central to this transition. How are they shaping the future of urban air mobility in NYC?
Dr. Emily Carter: These companies are at the forefront of the eVTOL revolution. Joby Aviation and Archer Aviation are leading the charge in developing eVTOL air taxi services, while Skyports and groupe ADP are working on the infrastructure side, ensuring that heliports like the one in Downtown Manhattan are ready to support these new aircraft. Their collaboration is essential for creating a seamless transition from traditional helicopters to eVTOLs, and their efforts could set a precedent for other cities around the world.
The Future of Urban Air Mobility in NYC
Sarah Thompson: As we look to the future, what do you think the rise of eVTOLs means for New York City and urban air mobility as a whole?
Dr. Emily Carter: The rise of eVTOLs represents a significant shift in how we think about urban air transportation. For New York City, it offers a promising path forward in addressing the long-standing issue of helicopter noise while also providing a more enduring and efficient mode of transportation.If successful, NYC could become a model for other cities grappling with similar challenges. The stakes are high, not just for residents seeking quieter skies, but for the future of urban air mobility itself.
