11 Yemeni Detainees Released from Guantánamo Bay After Two Decades Without Charge
on January 6, the Pentagon announced the resettlement of 11 Yemeni men to Oman,ending their over two-decade-long detention at the U.S. detention facility at Guantánamo bay. Thes men, held without charge since 2003, were part of a controversial chapter in U.S. history that began in the aftermath of the September 11, 2001, attacks. Their release reduces the number of detainees still held at Guantánamo to 15.
The decision to transfer these individuals was first communicated to Congress on September 15, 2023, by Secretary of Defense Lloyd Austin. The move has sparked debate, wiht critics arguing that it undermines justice for victims of terrorism, while proponents view it as a step toward rectifying a long-standing injustice.
A Legacy of Controversy
Guantánamo Bay has long been a symbol of the U.S. government’s approach to the Global War on Terror.The facility, established to detain individuals suspected of terrorism, has faced widespread criticism for its treatment of detainees and its circumvention of international law. Many of the detainees, including the recently released Yemeni men, were never formally charged or tried.
The concept of a “state of exception,” as described by German jurist Carl Schmitt, looms large over Guantánamo’s history. This principle suggests that sovereign powers can operate beyond the constraints of law in the name of public good. It’s a notion that has been wielded by leaders like former UK Prime Minister Boris Johnson and U.S. President Richard Nixon, often with contentious outcomes.
During the early 2000s, U.S. officials argued that the executive branch could bypass both international and domestic laws in the name of national security. The Geneva Conventions, as an example, were deemed inapplicable to terrorist suspects and Taliban fighters. In 2007, legal scholars Richard J. Delahunty and John Yoo reasoned that the U.S. president was not bound by international protocols, asserting that such limitations would undermine the Constitution.
The detainees: A Mixed Bag
The detainees at Guantánamo were a diverse group,many of whom were not captured on the battlefield but rather acquired through bounties in impoverished regions. As early as December 2002, Maj.Gen. Michael E.Dunlavey, the facility’s operational commander, complained about receiving “Mickey Mouse” detainees. An intelligence officer echoed this sentiment, stating, “There are a lot of guilty [people] in there, but there are also a lot of farmers.”
Over the years, many detainees endured torture, force-feeding, and the denial of basic legal rights. Their stories highlight the human cost of policies justified under the banner of national security.
The Road Ahead
The release of these 11 Yemeni men marks a meaningful moment in the ongoing debate over Guantánamo’s future. while their transfer has been celebrated by human rights advocates, it has also drawn criticism from those who beleive it undermines accountability for acts of terrorism.
As the U.S. continues to grapple with the legacy of Guantánamo, questions remain about how to balance national security with the rule of law. The facility, once a cornerstone of the Global War on Terror, now stands as a reminder of the complexities and controversies of that era.
| Key Details | Summary |
|————————————-|—————————————————————————–|
| Number of detainees Released | 11 Yemeni men |
| Duration of Detention | Over two decades (as 2003) |
| current Detainees at Guantánamo | 15 |
| Destination | oman |
| Announcement Date | January 6, 2025 |
| congress Notification | September 15, 2023 |
The release of these detainees is a pivotal moment in the ongoing effort to close Guantánamo Bay. It underscores the need for a transparent and just approach to addressing the facility’s legacy, one that respects both national security and human rights.
What are your thoughts on the release of these detainees? Share your perspective in the comments below.
The Lingering Shadows of Guantánamo Bay: A Tale of Militarized Care and Human Rights abuses
Guantánamo Bay, the U.S. naval station turned detention facility,has long been a symbol of controversy and human rights violations. Over two decades as its establishment, the facility continues to house detainees under conditions that have drawn sharp criticism from international bodies. A recent report by the United Nations Special Rapporteur on counter-terrorism and human rights,Fionnuala Ní Aoláin,sheds new light on the grim realities faced by those imprisoned there.
A Facility Built on Arbitrariness
Between February and May 2023, Ní aoláin conducted a “technical visit” to Guantánamo Bay, meeting with a wide range of stakeholders, including detainees, former detainees, military personnel, and families of 9/11 victims.Her findings,detailed in a June 2023 report, paint a bleak picture of systemic human rights abuses.
The report highlights the “arbitrariness” that pervades the detention infrastructure,leaving detainees vulnerable to abuse. many of those held at guantánamo were brought there “without cause and had no relationship whatsoever with the events that took place on 9/11,” according to Ní Aoláin. Detainees, both current and former, expressed a sense of despair, telling the rapporteur that she had arrived “too late.”
Militarized Care: A Contradiction in Terms
One of the most striking aspects of the report is its critique of what has been described as “militarized care.” By 2019, the Pentagon had begun planning for the eventual deaths of aging detainees, even drafting plans to build a hospice wing. This juxtaposition of care and cruelty underscores the facility’s paradoxical nature. As the U.S. government prepares for the end of life for its detainees, it continues to deny them the basic human rights necessary for a dignified existence.
The report notes that U.S. detention practices at Guantánamo constitute, at a minimum, “cruel, inhuman, and degrading treatment.” These practices include structural deprivations that strip detainees of their humanity, leaving them in a state of perpetual uncertainty and suffering.
Transfers and Repatriations: A Sketchy Process
The transfer and repatriation of detainees to third countries have also come under scrutiny. While the UN Rapporteur acknowledged “some positive evidence of international law and human rights-compliant practice,” the overall process remains deeply flawed. U.S. officials often rely on shoddy diplomatic assurances that former detainees will not face ill-treatment, only for many to be re-imprisoned, tortured, or denied urgent medical care.
Many detainees never consented to their transfer, further complicating their already precarious situations. The lack of accountability and follow-up by U.S. authorities has left former detainees in limbo,with little hope for rehabilitation or justice.
The Current State of Guantánamo
As of the report’s publication, the facility still holds a number of detainees. According to the Pentagon, three are eligible for transfer, three are undergoing assessment by the Periodic Review Board, seven are entangled in the military commission process, and two have been convicted and sentenced.
This ongoing detention of individuals, many of whom were never charged with a crime, highlights the travesty of justice that Guantánamo represents. the facility’s existence serves as a stark reminder of how power can corrupt even the most fundamental principles of justice.
| Key Facts About Guantánamo Bay Detainees |
|———————————————|
| Eligible for transfer | 3 detainees |
| Under Periodic Review Board Assessment | 3 detainees |
| Engaged in Military Commission Process | 7 detainees |
| Convicted and Sentenced | 2 detainees |
A Call for Accountability
The findings of the UN report underscore the urgent need for accountability and reform. The continued operation of Guantánamo Bay not only violates international human rights standards but also tarnishes the U.S.’s global reputation. As Ní Aoláin’s report makes clear, the line between the rule of law and the rule of the lawless is dangerously blurred at Guantánamo.
For those interested in learning more about the history and impact of Guantánamo Bay, the new York Times provides an in-depth look at the facility’s evolution and the challenges it poses.
The time has come for the U.S. to confront the legacy of Guantánamo and take meaningful steps toward justice and reconciliation. The world is watching.
—
What are your thoughts on the ongoing human rights violations at Guantánamo Bay? Share your opinions and join the conversation below.How to Write a News Article: A Step-by-Step Guide for Aspiring Journalists
Writing a compelling news article is both an art and a science. Whether you’re an aspiring journalist or a seasoned writer, mastering the craft of news writing requires a structured approach, attention to detail, and a commitment to delivering accurate, engaging content. Below, we break down the process into actionable steps, drawing insights from expert resources to help you craft stories that resonate with your audience.
1. Start with Thorough Research
Before putting pen to paper, invest time in gathering reliable details. “Do your research first,” advises Niche Pursuits[[1]]. This step ensures your article is grounded in facts and provides value to readers. Use credible sources, verify data, and cross-check details to maintain accuracy.
2. Structure Your Article Effectively
A well-structured news article follows a clear format: the inverted pyramid. Start with the most critical information—the who, what, when, where, why, and how—in the opening paragraph. Gradually delve into supporting details and background information. This approach keeps readers engaged and ensures they grasp the essentials even if they don’t finish the piece.
3. Prioritize Clarity and Conciseness
News writing thrives on brevity. As Grammarly[[2]]notes, “news articles prioritize delivering verified facts in a succinct, structured format.” Avoid jargon and overly complex sentences. Rather,opt for straightforward language that communicates your message clearly.
4. Incorporate Quotes and Attribution
Quotes add depth and credibility to your article. When including statements from sources, attribute them naturally within the text.For example, “According to [source], ‘direct quotes should be used sparingly but effectively to highlight key points.'”
5. Practice Regularly
Like any skill, news writing improves with practice.yellowbrick[[3]]emphasizes the importance of writing regularly, even if it’s just short news briefs or practice articles. Seek feedback from experienced journalists or editors to refine your craft.
6. engage Your Audience
A great news article doesn’t just inform—it captivates. Use descriptive language to paint a vivid picture, and vary sentence lengths to create a dynamic reading experiance. As an example, mix short, punchy sentences with longer, more elaborate descriptions to maintain reader interest.
7. Include Multimedia Elements
Enhance your article with relevant multimedia,such as images,videos,or infographics. These elements break up the text and provide visual context,making your story more engaging and accessible.
8. Summarize Key Points in a Table
To help readers digest complex information, consider summarizing key points in a table. Here’s an example:
| Step | Key Action |
|————————-|——————————————————————————-|
| Research | gather reliable information from credible sources. |
| Structure | Use the inverted pyramid format to organize your article.|
| Clarity | Write concisely and avoid jargon. |
| Quotes | Attribute quotes naturally and use them to highlight key points. |
| Practice | Write regularly and seek feedback to improve.|
| engagement | Use descriptive language and multimedia to captivate readers. |
9. Call to Action
Encourage readers to engage further with your content. For example, if you’re writing for a publication like International Policy Digest,invite them to submit their own articles or share their thoughts in the comments.
By following these steps, you can craft news articles that inform, engage, and inspire. Whether you’re covering breaking news or in-depth features,a structured approach and commitment to quality will set your work apart. Happy writing!
