One Reason the U.S. Can’t Quit China? Chips.
Chipmakers are finding it increasingly hard to operate in China but say doing business in the country is still key to their survival.
In May, Micron Technologies, the Idaho chipmaker, suffered a serious blow as part of the U.S.-China technology war. The Chinese government barred companies that handle crucial information from buying Micron’s chips, saying the company had failed a cybersecurity review.
Micron said the change could destroy roughly an eighth of its global revenue. Yet in June, the chipmaker announced that it would increase its investments in China — adding $600 million to expand a chip packaging facility in the Chinese city of Xian.
“This investment project demonstrates Micron’s unwavering commitment to its China business and team,” an announcement posted on the company’s Chinese social media account said.
Global semiconductor companies are finding themselves in an extremely tricky position as they try to straddle a growing rift between the United States and China. The semiconductor industry has become ground zero for the technology rivalry between Washington and Beijing, with new restrictions and punitive measures imposed by both sides.
U.S. officials say American products have fed into Chinese military and surveillance programs that run counter to the national security interest of the United States. They have imposed increasingly tough restrictions on the kind of chips and chip-making equipment that can be sent to China, and are offering new incentives, including grants and tax credits, for chipmakers who choose to build new operations in the United States.
But factories can take years to construct, and corporate ties between the countries remain strong. China is a major market for chips, since it is home to many factories that make chip-rich products, including smartphones, dishwashers, cars and computers, that are both exported around the world and purchased by consumers in China.
Overall, China accounts for roughly a third of global semiconductor sales. But for some chipmakers, the country accounts for 60 percent or 70 percent of their revenue. Even when chips are manufactured in the United States, they are often sent to China for assembly and testing.
“We can’t just flip a switch and say all of sudden you have to take everything out of China,” said Emily S. Weinstein, a research fellow at Georgetown’s Center for Security and Emerging Technology.
The industry’s reliance on China highlights how a close — but extremely contentious — economic relationship between Washington and Beijing is posing challenges for both sides.
Those tensions were reflected during Treasury Secretary Janet L. Yellen’s visit to Beijing this week, where she tried to walk a fine line by faulting some of China’s practices while insisting the United States was not looking to sever ties with the country.
Ms. Yellen criticized punitive measures China has recently taken against foreign firms, including limiting the export of some minerals used in chip making, and suggested that such actions were why the Biden administration was trying to make U.S. manufacturers less reliant on China. But she also affirmed the U.S.-China relationship as strategic and important.
“I have made clear that the United States does not seek a wholesale separation of our economies,” Ms. Yellen said during a roundtable with U.S. companies operating in China. “We seek to diversify, not to decouple. A decoupling of the world’s two largest economies would be destabilizing for the global economy, and it would be virtually impossible to undertake.”
The Biden administration is poised to begin investing heavily in American semiconductor manufacturing to lure factories out of China. Later this year, the Commerce Department is expected to begin handing out funds to help companies build U.S. chip facilities. That money will come with strings: Firms that take funding must refrain from expanding high-tech manufacturing facilities in China.
The administration is also weighing further curbs on the chips that can be sent to China, as part of a push to expand and finalize sweeping restrictions it issued last October.
These measures could include potential limits on sales to China of advanced chips used for artificial intelligence, new restrictions for Chinese companies’ access to U.S. cloud computing services, and restrictions on U.S. venture capital investments in the Chinese chip sector, according to people familiar with the plans.
The administration has also been considering halting the licenses it has extended to some U.S. chipmakers that have allowed them to continue selling products to Huawei, the Chinese telecom firm.
Japan and the Netherlands, which are home to companies that make advanced chip manufacturing equipment, have also put new restrictions on their sales to China, in part because of urging from the United States
What are the potential consequences for the global semiconductor industry if the United States were to sever ties with China?
One reason why the United States cannot sever ties with China is the semiconductor industry’s reliance on the country. While chipmakers are facing increasing challenges operating in China, they believe that doing business there is crucial for their survival.
In May, Micron Technologies, an Idaho chipmaker, faced a setback in the US-China technology war. The Chinese government banned companies involved in handling crucial information from purchasing Micron’s chips, citing a failed cybersecurity review. This change was projected to potentially eliminate one-eighth of Micron’s global revenue. However, in June, the chipmaker announced that it would be expanding its investments in China by adding $600 million to its chip packaging facility in Xian.
The global semiconductor industry finds itself in a challenging position as it navigates the growing divide between the United States and China. The industry has become a key battleground in the technology rivalry between the two countries, leading to the implementation of new restrictions and punitive measures from both sides.
US officials argue that American products have contributed to Chinese military and surveillance programs that go against US national security interests. Consequently, they have imposed increasingly stringent restrictions on the export of certain chips and chip-making equipment to China. In contrast, the US government is offering incentives such as grants and tax credits to chipmakers who choose to establish new operations in the United States.
However, the construction of new factories takes time, and corporate ties between the US and China remain strong. China is a major market for chips, as it houses numerous factories that produce chip-rich products like smartphones, dishwashers, cars, and computers, which are both exported globally and consumed domestically. China accounts for roughly one-third of global semiconductor sales, and for some chipmakers, it represents as much as 60% or 70% of their revenue. Even when chips are manufactured in the US, they are often sent to China for assembly and testing.
Emily S. Weinstein, a research fellow at Georgetown’s Center for Security and Emerging Technology, explains that abruptly severing ties with China is not feasible, as it is not as simple as flipping a switch and moving operations elsewhere.
Overall, the semiconductor industry’s reliance on China underscores the challenges posed by the complex and contentious economic relationship between the United States and China. This was evident during Treasury Secretary Janet L. Yellen’s recent visit to Beijing, where she criticized certain Chinese practices while emphasizing that the US did not seek to sever ties with the country.
