Adam Clayton not ordered to answer ‘inappropriate’ questions from plaintiff in song lawsuit by court

Adam Clayton, the bassist of the iconic rock band U2, has been granted a legal victory after a court refused to compel him to answer “inappropriate” questions from a man suing over a song. The case, which has been ongoing for several years, revolves around allegations that U2’s hit song “The Fly” was plagiarized from a demo tape submitted to the band by the plaintiff. In a recent ruling, the court confirmed that the questioning of Clayton had gone beyond the scope of the lawsuit and refused to force him to answer questions deemed irrelevant and inappropriate. This ruling marks a significant milestone in the music industry’s battle against frivolous lawsuits and the ongoing struggle to protect artists’ rights.


U2 bass guitarist Adam Clayton has successfully refused to answer “inappropriate” questions concerning a song on the band’s 2004 album, following a decision by Ireland’s High Court. A limited liability company, U2 Ltd, is being sued for €12m by Dublin man Maurice D Kiely, who alleges he wrote “A Man and A Woman”. Mr Kiely argues that he entered into an oral agreement with Mr Clayton allowing use of the song on the album on certain terms. The judge said that Mr Kiely’s memory did not appear “as infirm” as he claimed.


In conclusion, the recent verdict by the court refusing to compel Adam Clayton to answer ‘inappropriate’ questions from the man suing over a song reflects the importance of respecting one’s personal and private life. While it is important to seek justice and seek answers to legal disputes, it should not come at the cost of invading someone’s privacy or dignity. Ultimately, this ruling sets a precedent for future cases, emphasizing the significance of respecting individuals’ personal lives and privacy, even in the courtroom. As a society, we must strive to balance our pursuit of justice with empathy and consideration for the rights and dignity of all individuals involved.