2024 NFL Head Coaching Hires: Grades for Dan Quinn, Jim Harbaugh, and More
The NFL playoffs are reaching their climax, with Super Bowl LVIII just around the corner. While fans eagerly await the big game, the 2024 coaching cycle has come to an end, with several teams announcing new head coaches. With over 20% of the league having fresh leaders on the sideline next season, it’s an exciting time for football fans. However, the big question remains: how will these new hires fare? Let’s take a closer look at each head coaching addition and grade their performance so far.
Jim Harbaugh: Grade – A
Jim Harbaugh is no stranger to success. Having achieved great results everywhere he’s coached, including the NFL, Harbaugh brings a winning mentality to his new team. With a Super Bowl appearance under his belt and a talented roster already in place, Harbaugh’s return to the West Coast seems like a perfect match. His ability to build strong programs and create exciting offensive plays makes him a valuable asset for any team. With Harbaugh at the helm, the AFC West just got a lot more interesting.
Dan Quinn: Grade – D
Washington made the decision to part ways with Ron Rivera after four mediocre seasons. However, their choice to replace him with Dan Quinn, another defensively minded coach, raises eyebrows. While Quinn did lead the Falcons to a Super Bowl in 2016, his subsequent record of 18-23 with no playoff appearances is concerning. It remains to be seen if his experience can help rebuild the team, but this hiring lacks inspiration and innovation.
Raheem Morris: Grade – B
Four years after serving as an interim coach for the Falcons, Raheem Morris returns to Atlanta for a full-time opportunity. With previous head coaching experience and a successful stint overseeing the Rams’ defense in 2021, Morris brings a wealth of knowledge to the table. Highly respected in the league, Morris also benefits from adding assistant Zac Robinson to his staff. This hiring shows promise and could lead to positive results for the Falcons.
Dave Canales: Grade – B+
Impatience has been a recurring theme for the Carolina Panthers, with frequent changes in coaching staff and quarterbacks. However, their decision to hire Dave Canales as head coach represents a potential turning point for the franchise. With 13 years of experience as a Pete Carroll assistant in Seattle and a successful stint as the Buccaneers’ play-caller, Canales has proven himself as an ascending quarterback whisperer. His ability to accelerate Bryce Young’s growth under center could be a game-changer for the Panthers.
Jerod Mayo: Grade – C+
In New England, the question arises: is this a continuation of the same old Patriots or a new era under Jerod Mayo? Mayo, who has only played or coached under Bill Belichick, faces the challenge of differentiating himself from his mentor. While Mayo’s transparent approach and involvement in the team’s defense are positive factors, it remains to be seen how he handles offensive staffing and roster-building. The departure of Tom Brady in 2020 has left a void in the organization that Mayo must address to succeed.
Antonio Pierce: Grade – B-
The Raiders opted for a splashy outside hire in Antonio Pierce after a failed interim experiment in 2022. Known for his player-friendly approach, Pierce has garnered support from the locker room. However, with limited coaching experience, it’s difficult to gauge his long-term vision for the team. Like other former linebackers turned head coaches, his success will depend on personnel and staffing decisions. The Raiders are taking a gamble with this hire, and only time will tell if it pays off.
Brian Callahan: Grade – B-
Brian Callahan comes from a football family, with his father being longtime NFL coach Bill Callahan. With experience working with top quarterbacks like Peyton Manning, Matthew Stafford, and Joe Burrow, Callahan brings a wealth of knowledge to the Tennessee Titans. His intention to bring a modern offense to the team is an exciting prospect, especially after years of defensive-minded coaching. However, much of his success will hinge on his ability to develop a strong quarterback for the Titans.
Mike Macdonald: Grade – B
After 14 seasons under Pete Carroll in Seattle, the Seahawks have chosen to maintain a defensive approach by hiring Mike Macdonald. With experience coaching under John Harbaugh and a solid track record with the Ravens’ defense, Macdonald brings valuable expertise to the team. As the youngest head coach in the NFL, he has the opportunity to mold a young and talented defensive unit. However, his success will depend on how he handles the offensive side of the ball. This hiring brings intrigue and potential for the Seahawks.
As the 2024 coaching cycle comes to a close, it’s clear that each team has taken a unique approach in their head coaching hires. While some choices seem more promising than others, only time will reveal the